This comes down to 2 sports. Golf and Baseball, all other considerations fall way short when you compare the money and longevity.
Golf pays really well if you are one of the top 5 golfers out there. Tiger Woods is a unique situation that far surpasses any golf talent. Mickelson, Palmer, Norman and Els have all managed to creep up the salary rankings, but much of that money is a direct result of Tiger’s popularity. When he’s gone, Golf will slide back in the overall earnings potential. Those golfers that fall outside the top 5 fall way off, it’s a top loaded sport.
Baseball pays much better than golf regardless of endorsements. Most of the top athletes are all baseball players and the salary curve is a fairly flat one. A-Rod made $26+ million, but there were probably another 50 guys earning $10+ million. All that money comes regardless of your Q-rating.
So, if you are really going to be a goof-off, you want to be a baseball player. Baseball “preparation” is often discussed, but it’s almost inconsequential. It offers only a very small increase in a players performance over natural talent. Extensive effort in the weight room is helpful, but not required for a long productive career. Look at Tony Gwynn, CC Sabathia, Livan Hernandez, Ichiro and so on.
Golf, in contrast relies very heavily on preparation. Golfers spend hours and hours playing the courses they will be competing on to learn the angles and obstacles. They have to work constantly on the practice green and driving range to keep their swing consistent. Plus, and this is a deal breaker, they have to wake up at like 4AM in order to make early tee times!
Baseball players drink and womanize, roll out of bed around noon and maybe cruise over to the ballpark at about 5PM for night games. Manny Ramirez is the quintessential “talent”, he’s never read a pitchers scouting report and is typically unaware of who he’s playing against on a given day. He probably works out some, but he’s a long ways from a finely tuned physical specimen. His most rigorous off-field preparation is for his 12-step handshakes with teammates following homeruns.
A-Rod will earn over $600 million dollars before he retires, and he could become the biggest scumbag on earth and not lose a penny of that. If Tiger wakes up in the middle of a drug and whore scandal that $80 million he earns could become $5 million overnight when the sponsors back out. Seem like keeping you public image squeaky clean is as big a hassle as anything.
Baseball, at sunny Wrigley, for me please.