About 20 years ago, I remember seeing a news story about a patient with HIV who was given a bone marrow transplant, while the patient died (because of the disease which necessitated the transplant, not because of HIV) and the tests they ran on the patient after he/she had died revealed no signs of HIV anywhere in their body. The doctors then were saying, “This is not a cure.” (The reporter failed to ask why, despite my screaming at the TV for them to ask the question.) Interesting that this seems to have happened again.
I’ve seen too many failures in the war on HIV to get overly excited by this. Color me cautiously, mildly hopeful. But no more than that.
Especially given HIV’s ability to disappear from standard tests for its presence in the body, getting everyone excited that they’ve found a ‘cure’. Only to have it pop up again later. Often with a vengeance.
Yeah, this is one of the reasons that I always want to pick Magic Johnson in the Dead Pools. There’s just no way that whatever he’s done is the, ahem, magic cure.
Oooh, that makes today double exciting for me! They believe they have found a cure for Type 1 diabetes and since my boyfriend has Type 1 he is looking to possibly enroll in clinical trials to see if their cure is effective. The cure appears to have worked perfectly in pigs and there is a lot of hope that it will work in people too. I don’t personally know anyone with HIV but I know it has been a blight on humanity for many years now and a cure would be nothing but wonderful so a cure for HIV and a cure for diabetes both apparently coming about at the same time is almost magical to me!
Definitely is exciting, but as others have said it’s sort of “HIV breakthrough 4324” and we’re still no closer to a cure, so won’t be dumping the condoms quite yet.
Well, my take on why it wouldnt be considered a c ure is the sheer insanity of trying to crossmatch and arrange marrow transplants for all HIV + people.
What they probably consider a cure is a generic something [or group of somethings] that can be given to everybody. There are fairly serious risks to marrow transplant.
Yeah, I can see that as a problem, but for those few people that it could potentially cure (can’t say for certain that it would, of course, AFAIK there were no follow up studies) it’d be a lifesaver.
There are fairly serious risks to being HIV+, too. (Of course, undergoing a bone marrow transplant might well make those worse.)
Except that, based on the article I read (sorry, no link currently) the immunity seems to be some kind of genetic mutation. If they could just figure out how to tweak that one gene in everyone – immunization ensues**.
**Provided, of course there are no long-term genetic mutational problems, of course.
Well, this is it Litoris - the mutation of the goddam thing. I’ll always be excited and hopeful about any breakthrough but obviously it’s still going to be a long road and chances are an expensive one. Oh I hate HIV/AIDS with a vengeance.
Agreed on all points. I think the thing that makes me so anxious for a cure/immunisation/good treatment is the fucking stigma. Do we look at people with Hepatitis and assume they got it from sharing needles or unprotected sex? No. Why do we, knowing better, assume so much about HIV/AIDS? Ugh. Personally, I am hoping for a simple, cheap solution – but will be happy even if it turns out to be a hard, expensive one if we can give it to everyone.
I will continue to keep my fingers crossed that they figure something out that works. Even if this turns out to be a bust – it is at least a ray of hope.
Actually, an overwhelming “yes” based on my experience with clients and family members with Hepatitis C, all of whom acquired it though transfusions prior to 1992 and all of whom were treated as lying drug addicts by many professionals, which I witnessed at various times ranging from 1994 through about two months ago.
A cheap and simple solution is the only hope for the developing world. They have trouble enough getting the basic childhood vaccines, what with the problems with refrigeration and storage, let alone bone marrow transplants and engineered cells.
HIV won’t be beaten until we can offer those people some hope.