[QUOTE=Wendell Wagner]
When Delany moved from teaching at University of Massachusetts to teaching at Temple University a few years ago, Michael Swanwick remarked, “I guess that I can no longer claim to be the best science fiction writer in Philadelphia.”
[/QUOTE]
And since I bet that most of you are unfamiliar with Michael Swanwick, let me point out that he is definitely one of the best short fiction writers in the field today and his novels, while not quite up to that standard, are pretty good as well.
That science fiction, historically a field for outsiders, cannot attract black writers is a puzzle and a crime. All the leading black writers are anomalies, though Delany is closest to what should be a logical career path. He attended the Dalton School and the Bronx High School of Science, after all, and came from a distinguished upper-middle-class family. But he used to introduce himself when he spoke as a black gay Communist science fiction writer, thereby covering every touchstone of things normal people looked down on. The number of openly gay males in sf until very recently was about equal to the number of openly gay NFL players.
Butler was a lonely California girl who escaped from a grim reality into sf. There’s absolutely nothing in her background that would hint that she would become an sf star.
Steven Barnes is a hypnotherapist and martial artist, two occupations that are impossible to imagine being listed in the bios of any classic sf writer.
Nalo Hopkinson may be an exception, and a hope for the future. She went through a standard writing path, getting her MA in Writing Popular Fiction under the tutelage of James Morrow. (Another exceptional literary sf writer you’ve never heard of.)
None of them are very much like any other of them, in personality or style of writing. Ironically, Delany in the beginning kept being confused with Roger Zelazny, a poor white Polish kid from Baltimore. Back in 1970, James Blish wrote:
Of course, on the same page Blish wrote that when The Einstein Intersection won the Nebula, “I stepped quietly out into the kitchen and bit my cat.” Thus the old guard passes. 