I’m posting this on The Dope also, as I anticipate less than timely and helpful results from the “proper” forum, as outlined in my old thread about other message boards sucking ass. Feel free to look it up. Any way, here we go…
1989 BMW 325i (e30), 186k miles, ran pretty good considering the hard life its had. It broke a rocker arm, but instead of just fixing that, I decided to swap the head with a good one (I just happened to have sitting around), replacing the head gasket (guy who gave me the car years ago suspected it was bad, but I’ve been driving it for a while with little/no problems) at that time.
Anyway, the job went pretty smooth and got it all back together, but the cooling system ain’t right! I’ve tried to bleed it 15 different times and ways, but it still gets hot. I’ll fill up the system, bleed it and it will run correct for about 5 miles, heat blowing nice and hot. Then, the heat starts to get cool and the temp gauge will slowly creep up. Done this over and over with no success. Shut the car off, open the bleed screw in the thermo housing and you got steam. I’ve had the hoses off this thing several times before and never had this problem. Always bled and worked like a charm. Well, duh! Its got to be the head gasket/head repair gone wrong!
Here is the mystery part: Where is the water going? (only using water right now to test for leaks and problems. Once I had everything correct, I was planning on going with 50/50) System holds pressure, not getting water in the oil, no Old Faithful steam geysers or obvious leaks. Is it somehow getting out the exhaust as steam? Wouldn’t that eventually get into the oil? Wouldn’t it run like doo-doo?
I guess I know the obvious answer. My head gasket installation has gone wrong, but that’s the answer I don’t want to hear. I ran a compression test, and although not super, the figures are higher than before the head swap, and consistent on all six holes. Am I missing something else? Is the water pump crummy and not circulating enough? If so, how did it work before? Or does it just take forever for coolant to get through all those tiny holes in the new head gasket? I reject that as an answer!
Bad mechanic, stumped! Ignorant technician, befuddled! Sometimes I think I don’t deserve a BMW.
Thanks, Usual Suspects!