[QUOTE=Stratocaster]
So you have no issue with the declassification and sharing of the information with a single reporter, per se, correct?
[/QUOTE]
I accept that the declassification was legal, in a nose-holding kind of way. I don’t accept that this was simply a “sharing of the information with a single reporter”.
[QUOTE=Stratocaster]
It was in how the information was represented?
[/QUOTE]
That’s why I don’t agree it was simply sharing information - because it was a misrepresentation.
[QUOTE=Stratocaster]
Had Libby handed here a copy of the declassified portions of the NIE without comment or discussion, would you have no issue with that exchange?
[/QUOTE]
If you mean in the form it was disclosed in later, I think it would have been stupid of Libby to do that, being that he was pushing an angle that’s weakened by the disclosure of the document. I don’t understand why, with the mission he was given, he would do that.
If the document was declassified, and anybody could have access to it, as it was later on, I wouldn’t have a problem with that. And I’m not saying everybody should have a copy in their back pockets - I’m saying should anyone choose to, they could get at it. Not just Judith Miller.
[QUOTE=Stratocaster]
Also, this is from the NIE:Now, I’m not asking you if you believe this is true. I’m asking how the Times or anyone else can assess this is not a key judgment of the declassified NIE, whether or not they believe it. This is an honest question. Perhaps “key judgment” has a specific meaning in these circles.
[/QUOTE]
I take that clip as one of the key judgements, however “he remains intent on acquiring them” (nuclear weapons) or any other statement there is not the same as “vigorously trying to procure uranium”. At least in my book.
If there was solid evidence that Saddam was vigorously trying to procure uranium, you can bet it would have been up there as a key judgement, but it wasn’t.
[QUOTE=Stratocaster]
But even if that’s the case, it seems to me what Libby represented to Miller and what the declassified NIE contained is essentially the same. Disagreeing with the judgment is a separate issue than saying that something specific and unethical occurred in the exchange with Miller.
[/QUOTE]
What Libby presented to Miller wasn’t what he said it was. Yeah, it’s in the key judgements document somewhere, but Libby put it front and center when it was really just a disputed footnote.