[QUOTE=Apos]
Sure it is. If you can an audiotape of a conversation and you can attest to your voice on it and identify the other voices, that’s acceptable.
[/QUOTE]
No it’s not per se “acceptable” – not all by itself. The audiotape is hearsay, unless you get the tape in with a hearsay exception or the statements on the tape are being offered for non-hearsay purposes. Two hearsay statements don’t give you non-hearsay.
[QUOTE=Apos]
Likewise if you have a document attesting to what was said, like minutes or something, you can attest to being present and read them and confirm them
[/QUOTE]
Again, Not unless you get the document in with a hearsay exception or the statements in the document are being offered for non-hearsay purposes. Two hearsay statements don’t give you non-hearsay.
There’s a lot more to this.
The tape may be admitted (if it fits an exception or is being offered for non-hearsay purposes), the minutes may be admitted (if they fit an exception or are being offered for non-hearsay purposes), but in addition to hearsay problems, with a tape or a document you will need testimony to authenticate the tape or the document and you will need to satisfy the best evidence rule.
In your examples:
The audio-tape would still have to fit a hearsay exception or be non-hearsay (in criminal trials this these often come in as non-hearsay statements against interest or statements of co-conspirators (Rule 801(d)(2)).
Minutes would be admissible as a hearsay exception (Rule 803(6)) “records of regularly conducted activity”
Remember, the initial question was “is Libby’s testimony inadmissible hearsay?” The existence of an audiotape or document don’t change the answer to that question – his statement will still either be hearsay, non-hearsay or excepted hearsay – additional evidence to support his testimony will be just that, additional evidence
I was reluctant to continue this hijack, but it’s still kind of close to being on point