What are the odds of Bush and Kerry both being Skull and Crossbones members (and it being due entirely to chance) as has been widely reported in the media? Also, what is the known history of this organization? Most of what I have found concerning this organization is from “fringe” type websites (ie Alex Jones et al) and thus I don’t really trust the information. I figure there must be more “mainstream” sources of information, but I have yet to find them.
In addressing the primary question you may wish to consider the following factors:
Most Presidents come from a select few Universities. I think that LBJ was the only one who graduated from a State University for instance.
Most Presidents come from wealthy families.
Thus, what seems like a fantastic event may turn out to be rather mundane from a probability perspective. Not unlike the example often used in statistics classes about the odds of meeting someone with your exact birthday at a party (they turn out to be rather lower than one might expect, around one in thirty if I recall correctly).
I’m not disputing your calculation, but how did you arrive at your conclusion? Consider, that there are probably ten to fifteen colleges and Universities which have produced a disproportionate number of Presidents (and other politicians). How many fraternal organizations (of which the Skull and Crossbones is but one) are present at these places? I would think that the odds would be substancially higher than one in eleven even if we only considered Yale.
Yes you are correct. By the way the site that had information that I don’t trust was www.infowars.com . There has to be “mainstream” information on this group as well. I would think it interesting if they were both SAE members, let alone something as esoteric and controversial as this organization.