Camaraderie amongst Dopers stretches far and wide! Where do you stand?

Why do you love posting here so much? What is it that brings you back day after day hour after hour?

For the Newcomer, is it the thrill of having someone from a far off land answer your question? Is it he unbridled honesty that you like? Is it the mystery of not knowing what will come of what you write?

Is it the fact that this is a well run website with moderators keeping the trash out, and doing a damn fine job of it?

Is it the personal touch and/or nature of some of the posts?

I know I’ve asked some pretty deep questions here, I enjoy getting out of the everyday monotany and stepping into a virtual realm…It allows me to write freely, with little to no angst about what others feel about me. I’m sure for dopers who see each other socially, the experience is a little different, but for someone like me who has never been to a Dopfest or such…the experience is more novel. I had a student once who wore a Straightdope T-shirt, I got a good chuckle from that one. I never let him know I was a doper - but what I would have given to know who he was…It still bugs me and this was 4 years ago now.

So why do you like it here so much?

All of the above and more.

The Debates in GD and the Pit are amazingly engaging.

The chance to learn point of views from other countries has been great.

Meeting other dopers has been great.

Talking Baseball with fans that are not overwhelmingly Yanks, Mets and Phillies is fun.

Talking Tolkien with people, including yourself is always a joy. Long ago I used to post to a Tolkien chat room. It got old quick. Here it is occasional.
Speaking of which, maybe we need a Shire area Dopefest, seeing our locations. :wink:

This is the only place where I can discuss Tolkien, politics, learn more science from posters like **Colibri **, **Jshore ** and Stranger, and everything else that goes on in this crazy place.

Jim

A lot of what you write rings true to me, as well. Especially the “someone in a far off land” part. It’s fascinating to me that if I were to ever travel to Australia, or Europe, or East Asia, there are dozens of Dopers who would freely share their experiences with me of both living and visiting those places.

I also enjoy the community of “knowledge niches” coming together. I have my specialities, others have theirs, and we all kind of come together and satisfy each other’s curiosities. And often, the advice is actually quite practical (e.g. car repair and computer troubleshooting threads, among others).

Why do I love it here? You guys are my friends. :slight_smile:

Seriously, what I read here can influence how I think about things, can bring to sight different perspectives, and can allow me view things in a different light sometimes. It’s easy to communicate here without all the bullsh*t that seems to be in the air in so many other places. So many people can provide so much different information and no one HAS to be wrong. (This may not apply to The Pit. I stay out of there, as those people scare me.)

You guys are my first stop when I have questions, or want ideas, or just want someone to provide something to take my mind off of things for awhile. There is a sense of comfort when I go into a thread and see familiar “faces”. There are posters I look for and truly enjoy reading what they have to say. I know the ones who will make me laugh, make me think, and who can sometimes make me cry–sometimes all at once.

And, really, I’d be pretty lost if not for the LOST threads in Cafe Society…

What phall0106 said, I do more lurking than posting and I learn a lot.

I must say I love the Tolkein threads immensely and I too love talking with people from all walks of life, people who can tell me with clearity that I’m wrong about something, or that I’m on the right track…

I must admit some of the Trolls here have been pretty funny as well. What was the name of that guy a few years back BAMZOOL or something like that…he would g on and on and on with the most Schizophrnic rants! What fun he was to read! A little disturbing as well.

This is a 24-hour non-stop Quiz Show/Trivia Contest. I enjoy answering questions on subjects I know, and also trying to figure out the answers to ones I might not. Not to mention reading answers to questions that I’ve been curious about myself, or never even thought to ask.

And thanks to What Exit for the props.

Hey Colibri - it wasn’t until I bought a hummingbird feeder with your username on it that I fully understood what it meant :slight_smile: I always enjoy your posts.

Well, I see two of my reasons for liking this place. What Exit? and Colibri, have already been here. I enjoy the vast array of life experiences, expertise and opinions on display here. I enjoy the fact that many of the people who post here regularly write well enough that they have distinct voices and personalities for me. I enjoy the fact that many posters here are quite willing to correspond by email with me when I’ve had the urge to do so. I enjoy getting to know people from far and wide, and even getting to meet some of them in person.And I must say that I enjoy the goof balls who show up here too, mentioning no names. :wink:

This would be my answer, too. I was a long-time lurker who always enjoyed the Straight Dope columns. Haven’t really participated on Web boards all that much before, but except for the Great Debates section, the maturity level on this board strikes me as high. I don’t care for the Great Debates, because it seems to me to be just a bunch of slanging at each other and insults, but hey, I was a whiny git know-it-all when I was in university myself, so that’s okay. But the rest of the board is of higher quality than I’ve seen most elsewhere, which is only to be expected from anything connected with Cecil.

This place is the best on-line encyclopedia there is. Ask a question, posit a position…before too long there are a dozen experts answering, discussing, arguing the topic. It’s the beer-fueled bullshit sessions after work or in college to the Nth degree, except the people here actually know what they’re talking about. Even the people who don’t know what they’re talking about serve a constructive purpose, in serving as prompts for further discussion and clarification.

Dispite our quarrels, flaws and quirks, this is still the friendliest, most generous, most caring place I hang out, IRL or Virtually.

If you don’t like the comraderie, there are always the train-wrecks to watch. :smiley:

The above is one of the main reasons for me.

I also appreciate that I could ask any question, however stupid and have it answered without fear of being ridiculed.

I’ve seen many, many examples of Dopers showing generosity, care and concern for fellow Dopers that I haven’t seen on other boards.

The dope houses so many intelligent people from different walks of like.

No l33t or stupid avatars to deal with.

Even the majority of teens on here act mature and try to contribute positively.

Most of the dopers are very nice people that I could see being friends with outside of this little virtual world.

I’ve received excellent advice and support here that I’d never get on another board.

It’s not expensive.

The mods do a good job of keeping the arseholes at bay.

I really could go on but I haven’t the time.

It’s pretty much this… or actually do work.

Awww… it’s the feel-good thread of the century!

I’ve been here what… two months? Three? Something like that.

As I mentioned to someone else before in a PM, I am lonely Lisa Simpson and the Dopers are the New Girl with infinitely superior capabilities. On one hand, I’m elated to have found others like myself. On the other hand, I secretly fear that you’re all better than me and I’m just a posing idiot.

I love everything about the Dope Boards. I love all the opportunities to fight my ignorance on everything from foreign policy to lion taming. I love being able to speak to people who are living out things I learned about in the classroom (The ‘‘Ask a Former Cuban Communist’’ thread? Soooo exciting!) I love having my thoughts and beliefs and attitudes challenged… I call this my daily intellectual ass-kicking.

I don’t know how to properly explain this… but I’ll try.

I attend a VERY liberal public university. Things like affirmative action and LGBT rights and evilness of the Iraq war are taken as a given here (there are conservatives, they just cower in fear under their beds most days.) I’m not saying there is no intellectual challenge or critical thinking here–indeed, in many ways my university has taught me to think critically about all manner of issues. My university taught me to question the system and cultivate that bleeding heart o’ mine.

The Dope boards, however, have taught me to question the system that questions the system. In my short time here I have learned the value of rationality and empiricism in rooting out stupid arguments–even on my own side, even coming from myself. I am learning not only to be skeptical (sorry, Liberal, I’m a descriptive linguist, not a prescriptive one)–not only to be skeptical about others’ positions but to be skeptical about my own. I’m learning to call bullshit on things that seem true just because I feel strongly about them.

(Here’s a good example of what I mean. Have you ever read, ‘‘And the Band Played On,’’ a breakdown of the AIDS epidemic and how it was consistently ignored for nearly a decade before anybody took action on it? Well, part of that book which was so controversial is that the author demonstrated how the politics of the Castro district trumped common sense. Nobody in the district wanted to shut down the bathhouses even though they were the number one contributer to the spread of HIV–they saw it as just a political game, self-hating homosexuals trying to stop them from doing what they had fought for the right to do for so long. Because they clung so fiercely to these political ideals, they ignored the science and the impassioned warnings and people died.)

In a way, The Dope Boards have taught me how not to be the Castro district, they’ve taught me not to shoot myself in the foot because of my own emotions, but to look at the facts and evaluate them based on their own merit.

I am not saying I am perfect in this regard, but I am learning. And the gift of critical thinking is something miraculous and impossible to return, thus my irrational emotional commitment to the Boards. It’s like a family here. Some Dope members despise others, but–well like I said, it’s like a family here. If I had my way we’d all live in the same apartment complex and have regular backyard BBQs. I feel that you are all authentic and good people–and a lot of you have many years on my piddly 23 so I have much to learn from the wisdom of my elders. :stuck_out_tongue:
SDMB is valuable not only for the intellect but for its great compassion. There is a warmth and a humor here that I have never found anywhere else. My favorite author is Lewis Carroll – extremely intelligent, extremely witty, and extremely compassionate all in one swoop. You guys are the Lewis Carroll of the internet. And the outpouring of support I recently received when I was going through my rough time will never be forgotten. I know this is a safe place, and I value that like I can’t describe.

I hope I’m getting across my message clearly. I think it might be a little sad how much I care about this board and how much I consider it to be a part of my life. Ah, well. I’m in good company. :slight_smile:

It’s good shit. It’s cheap, and it even saves you money on repairs and opinions and such.
My dad likes to come on here and bitch and complain about things. Grandpa Simpson indeed.

/New New York police robot/ Smells nice too! Aaaaaah yeahhhh! /New New York police robot/

But seriously, also very many threads here are a thrilling read, and you just have follow up on them. Like the werewolf game thread, and that 70’s wallet thread.

For once I get my ass handed to me in debates. Some of the ones I’d like to contribute to I read and am so thoroughly blown away by the depth and perception of the arguments I don’t even bother responding. Of course, some of them I’m blown away by the ability of those same posters to totally ignore 90% of a post and respond with what they wanted the other guy to post, but hey!
GQ is an amazing repository of all sorts of information and new information.
The Pit is hilarious.
All sorts of great stuff here.

Personally, I like the pie.

Olives - you are not the Lonely Lisa Simpson! You are the incredibly valued olivesmarch4th. A contributing member of a great society…