I haven’t posted for a while because this is like banging your head against the wall. Politically, now, I think it is a very interesting dynamic playing out.
Flake is an uncertainty right now. But if there is one person right now who I predict will get Collins and Murkowski to hold serve, it is: (drum roll) Joe Manchin.
Here in West Virginia, he has a comfortable, but not huge lead. If he votes against Kavanaugh, I predict he loses. There is a month left for attack ads that old “liberal Joe” votes against guns, for abortions, and now against conservative judges. If he votes to confirm Kavanaugh, he gets to play the “I’m an independent Democrat and I call them how I see them and I am for West Virginia” and he wins.
The flip side of this is that if the vote is 50-50 with Pence breaking the tie and Manchin is one of the yes votes, his career in the Senate will be serving on the Towel Restocking Committee for the Senate locker room.
So his political calculus is almost certainly that he has to vote yes, but cannot be the deciding yes. However, to pull off this trick, he cannot come out now as a yes. That’s why I believe that his recent comments (I will look at his adult life…as a father) signal that he will be pressing behind the scenes for confirmation in the typical aw shucks Joe way.
As far as Flake, Murkowski, and Collins, it is difficult to see why they would have insisted on an FBI investigation, see that nothing has come from it, yet still vote no. We are exactly where we were before Ford’s allegations came out.
If you were a Kavanaugh supporter prior to the allegations, then I see nothing that has surfaced with any sort of evidentiary support that would change your mind. If you were a Kavanaugh opponent, then the allegations have certainly not changed your mind. And if you were on the fence, I see a bloody draw that has damaged both Kavanaugh and Ford that would leave you to decide the case on the merits of the status quo ante.
All of this has taught me to make sure that my daughter never, ever, ever does anything bad or posts stuff on social media that is the least bit controversial. That is the sad result of this process.