A year ago when we had the mega-trainwreck threads about not giving legal advice on message boards, some posters were doubtful that there could ever be any legal consequences, asking if anyone has ever been sued over legal advice on message boards.
There is in fact a defamation lawsuit now chugging along in the courts in Ontario, Canada, in which lawyers who posted on one message board are being sued for their comments about legal advice given on another message board.
The background is that there were two different message boards, both dedicated to talking about legal issues: advicescene and lawbuzz.ca.
Some posters on lawbuzz.ca are alleged to have posted comments calling into question the accuracy of the free legal advice given on advicescene.
The operators of advicescene then sued the operators of lawbuzz.ca, which settled on the condition that it revealed the IP info for the posters in question. The operators of lawbuzz.ca then ceased operations.
Now the operators of advicescene are suing some of the posters on lawbuzz.ca for defamation, who appear to be lawyers themselves. The suit is still in early stages in the courts, so of course it’s not possible to say who’s in the right here.
The twist here is that the one website openly offers free legal advice, and is suing those who are alleged to have commented disparagingly on that free legal advice.
However, it certainly shows that commenting on legal advice on-line can carry much the same potential legal consequences as commenting in person, or in writing.
Two articles on the issue:
Online Comments Spark Messy Litigation - 01 February 2010
Lawbuzz Suit Ups Ante Names Three More Lawyers - 24 May 2010