Catch Me If You Can

I saw the film with Leonardo DiCaprio called Catch Me If You Can not too long about about the exploits of legendary con-man Frank Abagnale during the 60s and early 70s. In today’s world is any of that experience remotely possible with the level of monitorization that takes place, etc?

  1. Could someone pose as a pilot and deadhead for free by making a fake ID badge?

  2. Could someone really pose as a doctor in a rural facility?

  3. Is check fraud really that easy today and does it happen much with all the precautions taken place?

  4. Is it really possible to pass yourself off as an educator in todays world whether it be a professor or a high school teacher without having the credentials?

It seems to me and perhaps this is just an out there premise but it seems to me as if individuals who commit fraud as Frank Abagnale did are individuals who have taken advantage of society’s trust and used it to their advantage (and by no means is that an excuse for it!)

People have done all of those things recently. #3 is still common. I will try to find good examples of fairly recent news stories. You left out some similar examples like could someone fake their educational background and get a very high level job like CEO or a high-level position at an elite university? The answer to that is yes too because people have done it and are likely doing it undetected (for now) today?

Would you believe that the Dean of Admissions for MIT of all places faked her degrees and did not have any herself.

Here is a fake pilot imitating the movie in question. He was allowed into the cockpit before he was caught but he is only one example of many.

Fake doctors are not rare at all. Many of them were once ‘real’ doctors stripped of their licenses who found a way to practice illegally but others never had any real medical training to begin with.

Here are 10 high-profile executives that never got the degrees that they claimed. One of the more notorious is former Yahoo CEO Scott Thompson who claimed he had a computer science degree when he didn’t. You can see why that might be a problem for a multi-billion dollar tech company.

If you want truly brazen and unbelievable, here is an American teen that posed as an OB/GYN in a hospital. He was caught - after a month on the ‘job’.

It still can be done, though it’s probably harder than in Abagnale’s day. But in many cases, all it requires is chutzpah.

It’s also possible that Frank Abagnale’s con wasn’t impersonating all those professions successfully; it was writing a book in which he convinced readers he impersonated all those professions successfully. Abagnale was often vague about the details and when the organizations where he claimed he worked were contacted, they denied he had worked there. Abagnale said this was because they were embarrassed at having been fooled so they were covering up. But it seems strange that nobody has been able to produce a paper record showing his job history.

The pilot thing cited above happened in Italy, not the US.

In the US there’s a national database with every airline pilot ID card & picture. You’re not getting on another airline’s jumpseat without them verifying your ID in the big database. They can see the rider’s ID card, and the picture, so they have a good chance to detect a fake ID card even if it’s from an airline they’ve rarely or never seen before. If somebody is grounded or fired, switching them off in the database is done instantly, to prevent disgruntled ex-employees from doing evil.

Similarly on one’s own carrier the internal database must be consulted during the process of setting up the reservation & such. The gate agent might be a little sloppy looking at somebody in the right uniform and with a good looking fake ID card of the right carrier. But getting the reservation put together will be kinda hard.

Once a would-be jumpseater gets to the cockpit to ask permission to ride, we’re required to hand-inspect their company ID, pilot’s licence, FAA medical certificate, and passport or driver’s license. And we do. Plus the boarding pass the agent could have issued only after checking the national database, etc.

The system’s not impervious against CIA-level adversaries. But it’s not like the old days of Abignale where anyone with the gift of gab and a bad photocopy of an ID card could cadge a ride.

That first link is creepy as all get out.

The second link, about a teen caught “posing” as a doctor, is not a good example. The kid never got any money, never saw a patient, and the hospital claims he never even got access to any patient areas. He apparently just wandered the halls, ate in the cafeteria, and drank coffee with the hospital personnel. His mother said he had [undisclosed illness] and ahd been off his meds.

In Germany, a former mailman by the name of Gert Postel successfully imposted physicians and psychiatrists in government service. He pulled this off twice, for the first time in 1982/83 as a public health officer (for which he received a suspended sentence) and for the second time from 1995 to 1997 as a senior physician at a clinic for forensic psychiatry. He was so good at his job that he was considered for a professorship. His true identity was only uncovered accidentally, in the 1980s when he lost his wallet and in the 1990s when he stumbled upon a woman who recognized him.

People impersonate professions all the time., some even legally. PI’s/police detectives do it to get information/surveillance footage. As long as you don’t actually practice medicine or law it’s not a crime to impersonate being a doctor or lawyer. 'Course, if a doctor or lawyer were to impersonate being a cop, that would be a crime. :smiley:

It’s the longevity that counts. Doing it for a few minutes or hours is one thing. Abagnale allegedly did it for weeks, months, and years. Tough to pull off.

I met Frank back in the late 90’s. He taught a course on fraud detection that a lot of cops and other types of investigators took. I gotta tell you, the guy could charm the birds out of the trees. And that’s how he pulled off all his crimes. And it’s how a lot of con men pull it off. They just have the right personality for it.

In response to such impersonations, and with heightened security thanks to hijackings starting in the 70’s, it has been tougher and tougher to get away with this sort of thing. Abignale was lucky to be doing his thing at just the right time. At the time, a pilot was a hugely prestigious job, air travel was pretty expensive and rare and international travel, even more so. Cheque cashing took a long time so someone could cash a cheque and be long gone before the fraud was discovered. (Heck, there’s a similar internet purchase “send me the change from this certified cheque” fraud that was going around recently).

All the controls over airports in the last few decades have combined to make it pretty much impossible to “fake your way” in. The airport ID cards I’ve seen have bar codes and probably microchips, because they are waved or swiped to open locked doors - also (I assume) meaning they are validated in real time against a central computer system. I suppose you could fake one, but the first time it was scanned, it would trigger alarms. I haven’t looked closely, but would be surprised if they didn’t have the same holographic and UV security features as drivers’ licenses.

Printing was a rare and complicated business, so something that looked professional and printed appeared genuine. (There’s a scene in the movie where he’s faking a Pan-Am payroll cheque by using the decals for a model airplane as company logos on the cheques.) In this day where home colour laser printers and photo printers are cheap, we forget how recently laser-print quality required expensive equipment and a lot of processing. So Frank’s scams cashing cheques are harder to do today. In those days credit cards were pretty much non-existent, so things were done with cash. With all the problems cheques bring, I see more and more businesses today don’t bother accepting cheques except from established customers. His scam of cashing massive numbers of cheques in Europe (and across the USA) also benefited from the fact that long distance was painfully expensive and even extremely difficult from some foreign countries, so validating cheques by phone was not routine.

Similarly - a number of factors have come together to make faking being a doctor (or anything) a more difficult proposition. Records generally are online. Even the most rural facility can hook into internet connections to be part of various networks. The problems with drugs have made controls on prescriptions more strict; most state medical bodies have authorizations online. If caught nowadays, the un-doctor would immediately face far more serious felony drug charges for fake prescriptions, in addition to practicing without a license - unless they never wrote a prescription. Not to mention sexual assault charges if he did clothing-optional exams.

There was a discussion here earlier about faking being a lawyer, the general conclusion being most states track lawyers accredited to the bar, and unless you could steal the identity of an accredited lawyer, faking your way in was almost impossible; and in a small professional community, it’s likely you would run across someone who knew the real person.

I suppose being isolated in a rural community and medicine having less interaction, it might be easier to get away with. For things like Medicare. likely there’s a registration process and the fake doctor 9a) is more likely to be found out and (b) billing Medicare without accreditation is a fraud felony. However, modern medicine’s modus operandi is that a patient needing more involved treatment is referred to a specialist by a doctor - presumably a doctor making too many errors would attract the attention of the nearest community of specialists, and eventually bring on investigations from the medical board.

OTOH if you want to dress up as a doctor and wander the hospital - nowadays, thanks to problems like this, ID cards are pretty much mandatory, doors are locked and require keycard access, etc.

(I recall a news item about a some rural Nova Scotia town who lost their not-a-doctor. The fellow got away with it for several years, with some elementary knowledge, medical textbooks, and ordering far too many tests.)

In the movie “Parker” real estate agent Jennifer Lopez mentions to Jason Statham that she figured out his false identity - his credit record only began 6 months earlier. Former soviet spy “Jack Barsky” even 40 years ago used the excuse that he had been working on a farm to excuse getting an SSN in his late 20’s because it seemed suspicious. Nowadays, your identity is a compendium of your paper trail of past activity from birth, school, college, drivers’ license history, credit history, IRS tax records, etc. Faking a full-fledged, relatively correct identity is almost impossible unless you are the CIA and have government access to many record sources. Stealing an identity has its own risks and difficulties.

So in general, things are much more locked down and secured than they used to be. We can thank everything from terrorism to petty theft to drugs for the prevalence of security, and computers for making it much harder to fake your way in. the fifties and early sixties were a magical time for fakes and cons, as long as you were white, male and educated. Things are much harder today.

The “Great Imposter” was real (Fernand Waldo Demara). he successfully impersonated a Canadian navy doctor, a catholic monk, a prison warden. He was caught when he used a fake ID (belonging to a real Canadian doctor.

It’s time now for a new re-make of the move “Catch Me If You Can”, starring Joaquin Guzman.

It hasn’t been explicitly mentioned in this thread so I’ll add it: Abagnale never piloted a plane, he just rode for free in the courtesy jump-seat. He posed as a doctor as cover and spent 10 days as an administrator. You can listen to Abagnale give a fascinating talk about his fraud life here: 2015 Presentations (5th video).

On cheque fraud - if you come to the UK and try to buy something with a perfectly legitimate cheque, you will be treated with great suspicion. Many businesses will not even accept them from established customers.

I have questioned this myself. I really liked the movie, so I bought a used copy of the book on Amazon–I never finished it. The Frank Abagnale of the movie seems to be a cool cat, suave and always coming out on top; the Frank Abagnale of the book seems to be a cocky arrogant snot.

This is one movie where I was happy that they applied sufficient artistic license to diverge from the book enough to make it good.