rosaries are one of my “collectibles” categories. i’ve probably got a couple hundred by now (thanks, eBay! thanks, antique stores and thrift shops!)
my first one, from First Communion, was a lovely irregular round glass bead in a light blue shade, complete with matching light blue leatherette, velveteen-lined pouch. (still have it.) i bought a fancy gilt silver-filigree one with matching filigree container when i was in Rome as a souvenir for my grandmother, which i took back when she died. (my own personal, much smaller one vanished when my purse was stolen. : sniff : )
but enough about my collection. generally speaking, since i have so many now, what i look for is, in no particular order of importance: [ul]
- unique bead - could refer to color, shape, material (semi-precious stone), images on/in bead
- unique hardware - center medallion or crucifix that does not look like all the other cookie-cutter findings (unique shape, design elements, additions (enameling, stones, etc.))
- overall attractiveness - there are zillions of crystal-bead rosaries out there (well, in here too), but if i see one that just seems to stand out for some reason, i might well buy it.
- overall uniqueness - handmade (but WELL-made), precious or semi-precious materials, one-of-a-kind case or holder for said rosary, decade beads different from ordinaries. [/ul]
to answer another of your questions – most rosary owners/buyers don’t have a clue if the maker is Catholic, Buddhist or a three-toed sloth. it shouldn’t make any difference what your personal beliefs are, as long as your product is attractive and well-made. (i cannot stress the “well-made” portion enough. i’ve gotten some ‘hand-made’ rosaries that i looked at and thought “sheesh, i can do better than that myself”. which i can, too, since i make jewelry as a hobby.)
and there is always a specific male market for rosaries… a good percentage of priests and other male religious say the rosary as part of their daily prayers. however, they are most likely to lean towards the utilitarian and plain when it comes to looks.
so if you’re looking to make something that would stand out from the crowd, i’d think along lines of unique beads you could make. i wouldn’t make them much larger than 8-10 mm max, however, because the end product will wind up being quite long (and a trifle unwieldy). similarly, a smaller bead is less likely to get split or broken when the rosary ends up in the bottom of a purse or pocket. larger/differently shaped decade-marker beads would be ok, but i wouldn’t advise an entire rosary made out of 8mm long oval beads. (generally speaking, if i were doing it, i’d tend to 6mm ordinaries, with 8 or 10mm decades.)
but unique color combinations would be a big draw for me. one of my favorites is the one my MIL gave me–beads are (um, lemme think)… faceted trianglish (blunt ends) glass, but have a color play from blue to green within the beads themselves.
and remember – any projections WILL most probably get chipped or broken, unless this is a display-only piece.