Characters from different fictional universes who would be instant best buddies.

Another Dragon Age one:
Fiddler and “Warden Blackwall”

Good

Oh, yes, very good

I don’t know - snobbery was about the only vice Kirk did NOT have.

Kirk was in fact based partially on Hornblower.

That’s happened. There was a Marvel/DC crossover in 1996 that had the two manipulating Superman and the Silver Surfer.

But, er, the two did not become friends. :slight_smile:

Hornblower was not a captain or a letch.

Donald Duck and Daffy Duck

Are you disputing that Kirk was based on Hornblower? That’s very well established. Roddenberry’s original pitch described Kirk as “a space-age Horatio Hornblower.” That doesn’t mean that every aspect of their personalities match.

In any case, of course Hornblower was a captain. He rose through the ranks from midshipman to admiral.

I think Buffy Summers would make an excellent companion on Doctor Who. She’d call the Doctor “Giles”, and he’d gently admonish her for stabbing all the aliens.

You’re right, I misspoke; Hornblower did not begin a captain in his series. Another significant difference between Hormblower and Kirk.

Just because one character was based on another does not mean they would have been best friends.