chiropractors....I ain't sure

I’m glad that you didn’t advise me of this ten years ago. A rough parachute opening shock while skydiving left me with some pretty severe neck pain for a week or so, and six weeks after the incident I decided to have it looked at. I was skeptical of chiropractic even then, and I went to see a GP. He took a few X-rays, and didn’t see anything… on the first look. But he thought he saw a funny shadow, so had me take another image with my head bent down. That image showed my C2 vertebra (the Christopher Reeve one) opened up wide, which it did every time I bent my head down.

I know that a chiropractor could have seen this if he was being careful, but it scares the hell out of me to think what might have happened if a chiro had overlooked it and attempted a manipulation on my fragile C2.

CurtC wrote:

If you survived, you may well have suffered the fate of Christopher Reeve. If not…well, look at this:

The Spin Doctors Investigation
http://www.canoe.ca/ChiroYork

Never let anyone, MD, DO, PT or DC manipulate the first two cervical vertebrae (C1 & C2). Mobilization, yes. But not manipulation. And if a DC calls it an “adjustment”, beware: he’s probably looking for those pesky “subluxations”, which EVERYONE has myriads of, and which cause ALL diseases! And he’s got only ONE cure-all: adjustments!..=:0(

Paul Lee, PT
Denmark

E-mail - healthbase@post.tele.dk
HF List Intro. - http://www.hcrc.org/wwwboard/messages/197.shtml
The Quack-Files - http://www.geocities.com/healthbase


I wouldn’t be so quick to dismiss chiropractors. PTs, MTs, MDs, DCs, DOs, I know them all and each is good for maladies in their own field.

Physical therapy - untouched in rehab, these are the only guys who can do it.

Massage therapy - there are some good ones, but because of the educational requirements, most are not expert in injuries, better for back rubs.

Chiropractors - Again due to low education standards, there are a lot of quacks around, and I mean a lot of them. But untouched in certain types of problems. Sometimes manipulation or mobilization IS needed for pain relief and you better believe it. I have low back pain which is relieved by manipulation, and I wouldn’t trust PTs, MTs, or MDs to do it. It’s just that DCs do this everyday, they get good at it. Just make sure it’s a problem that manipulation will help first.

DOs (Osteopaths). Same as MDs in the US, but not in other countries (e.g. UK, Australia). Depends on what they want to specialize in. There are DOs who are OBs or pediatricians. Some specialize in back pain. But dirty secret is that some hospitals or schools will not take DOs as staff.

MDs: Internal meds or family practice, pretty much clueless as regards LBP, NP, etc.

MDs: (specifically orthopedists). Don’t get them mixed up, these guys are not trained in manipulation, they look at things from a surgical point of view. Mainly good for severe stuff, not for your run of the mill LBP. And you better believe fusions are done when they shouldn’t have been. I don’t believe orthos are much good for things like LBP.

As in anything, there are incompetents and morons in each field (what is the person graduating last in med school called? Ans: Doctor).

And stay away from chiros who say they can cure cancer etc., actually report them to the state medical or chiropractic board.