Churchill (2017 film) (spoilers)

As anyone else seen this movie?

Brain Cox plays the titular character in the period immediately before D-Day. I thought it would be a good companion piece to Ike: Countdown to D-day, with Tom Selleck.

I went in with no information. I didn’t even know it was Brain Cox playing Churchill - since they have no opening cast credits, it took me half the film to recognize his voice.

I thought it was a good film, and Cox did a great job. My complaint is that it appears to be whatever the opposite of a hagiography is - Churchill is portrayed as inept and wrong and just simply a tired old guy still fighting the last war, a guy who is simply “in the way”. I kept waiting for Churchill to do something to show he still had it, but that never came.

There’s a scene where is is literally praying for rain, so as to cancel D-day (which he was afraid would be another Gallipoli). To me, it was never shown that Churchill might just have a different, educated, opinion. No, Churchill was portrayed as absolutely wrong.

Instead of him realizing that Ike and Monty knew what they were doing, the King had to tell him personally to step aside, to be basically a cheerleader. They just gave Winnie a cookie and a pat on the head, and sent him to bed. “Let the adults talk.” I’ll have to rewatch, but I don’t remember Chruchill being treated so poorly in Ike: CtD-D.

But, as a study of a once-powerful man, diminished by what might be undiagnosed bipolar disorder, it isn’t a bad film. :slight_smile:

And James Purefoy as George VI was great.

I saw this over the weekend.

All-in-all, I thought it was a very enjoyable piece of “docudrama.” Brian Cox did a great job as Churchill, and James Purefoy was very believable and human as the King. After seeing it, I read up a bit on Churchill and Operation Overlord, and the movie distorts his opposition to the assault - by the timeframe of the movie (3 days before D-Day), he had already come on-board with the plan. But, that would have been a less interesting, if more accurate film.

So, this is Churchill’s “The Order of the Phoenix,” where he gets to be grumpy and angry and depressed most of the movie in order to be redeemed at the end.

There were some predictable characters (Helen, the secretary, I’m looking at you). leading to predictable Hollywood scenes, but i guess those are unavoidable these days.

So, if you are a stickler for historical accuracy, or want your heroes unsullied by doubts, this isn’t the film for you. Other than that, an nice way to get out of the heat.

After seeing Cox in Super Troopers, I don’t think I could ever see him do anything again and keep a straight face. :smiley:

So it’s basically a hit-piece? Thanks. I now know to not go see it.