Clothes vs Toys For Charitable Christmas Donations

Work is doing the yearly local charity donation drive, this year with a place that is basically pre-K combined with homelessness charity. Unlike some years, it’s pretty open-ended in that there’s a number of children with their current clothing size but nothing actually requested, and the guidance from HR was to get one thing, so like a reasonable outfit (like just a shirt/pants combo) or a toy. And of course nothing too crazy in cost (there’s not a limit set but I’m thinking $15-20 is reasonable). But the opinion I’m looking for is if it’s better to get something somewhat more useful (a good outfit for the winter) or something a kid might be more excited about (a reasonable toy that doesn’t take batteries or have a lot of parts to keep track of). Knowing of course at that age even clothes might be exciting.

Honestly, my first instinct is a nice toy, maybe a stuffed animal or something. But I don’t know enough about what parents involved with such a program would find more useful or would want to see their kid get. So I’m asking here since I know there’s a wide range of actual experience.

You could call the place. Even if nothing has been specifically requested, the folks who work there know what they most need.

My company does the toy drive thing some years and I bought some Lego sets in the $20-30 range that came in a nice carry box. Sometimes I bought some sort of Barbie-like doll.

Regarding toys, I would recommend things like coloring books and a set of crayons, or beginning-reader books, unless the child or family has requested something specific.

And even if they do, most kids that age would be delighted to get a coloring books, etc. featuring Peppa Pig, Spongebob, etc.

The toys might be the only gift the child gets. And it may be the only thing the parent can give. I would get the toy.

I vote for the toy too, unless a very specific request was made for clothes. Kids need toys as much as clothes, maybe more.

This. Useful stuff is the every day quest of people in need. Something fun, a distraction from being forever in survival mode, is humanizing. Everybody deserves a little lightness, even the destitute.

More.

Having worked with the homeless as a City Commissioner, the homeless told us they have plenty of clothes- the exceptions being :

Socks, nice warm socks, or hell just clean socks. I called a guy I know and got a deal on 4 dozen pairs of mismatched seconds warm winter (many wool) socks, and they were greatly appreciated. I even heard they were being traded for a while as a form of currency!

Underwear

Women’s interview outfits/suits. This can get a woman out of living in her car and back into a real job and housing.

In some areas- a warm, weather proof coat.

Best toys are something portable, sturdy and not easily lost. iirc. For a boy, a toy truck, for example.

Once I bought my son a package of socks that was too small for him. I only found out after I’d opened the package and washed them. So I sent them to his school with a note that teachers/aides could give them out as needed.

Did they ever. It was a wet, muddy day and little kids were coming in with cold, wet feet. I heard that aides from different classes would open his classroom’s door, saying, “Somebody said you had clean socks!”

I did this again later.

Several years ago, I was involved in a local underwear collection project, and while they said they always needed socks, the one demographic that seemed to be consistently overlooked was underwear for grade-school aged boys.

Good on you!

I am reminded of a Dave Berg cartoon in Mad magazine eons ago where a kid is on the phone, being coached by his Mom.

“Hi, Aunt Betsy. Thank you for the underwear you gave me this year – it’s really nice.”

“Tell your mother she’s welcome.”