*“Dying is easy. Comedy is hard.” *
the probably apocryphal final words of Edmund Kean (1787-1833)
Inspired by this thread, who are some very talented comic actors who’ve given some great but decidedly non-comic performances? A few that come to mind:
Carol Burnett in Friendly Fire = in one of her first turns after playing Eunice and Mrs. Wiggins for 13 years, Carol blew critics and fans away as the mother of a Vietnam casualty. Her scene at his casket was literally breathtaking.
John Cleese in “Francis Ford Coppola’s” “Kenneth Branagh’s” Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein - this was a dreadful movie (Branagh is firmly convinced that “draggin’ capes automatically equal tense drama”) but a hoary maned Cleese was perfect as Victor Frankenstein’s brilliant mentor Waldeman.
Jerry Lewis in The King of Comedy = while the movie could be argued to be a very dark comedy, Lewis had a decidedly straight role as the megalomaniacal late night talk show legend. He gave a much better performance, imho, than in any of those godawful Dean Martin pictures that somehow became classics.
Don Rickles, Dick Smothers and Alan King in Casino = it was brilliant casting to use Vegas fixtures in this piece, but Rickles surprised me most as the much-put-upon nebbish manager of the titular Casino. He actually wasn’t annoying for once.
Steve Martin in And the Band Played On - while Steve Martin has given many non-funny performances, this time it was intentional as he plays the nameless brother of an early AIDS victim in a cameo.
Lily Tomlin in And the Band Played On and Tea With Mussolini - as a medical investigator in the first and a trapped archaeologist in the second, she was an excellent supporting performance. (I believe her role in Mussolini was her first openly gay character.)
Elizabeth Montgomery will always be known as Samantha, but she shone in several movies including .The Awakening Land (about which not enough good can be said- this was to historical miniseries what The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman was to made-for-TV historical movies), The Legend of Lizzie Borden and Sins of the Mother.
Comic actors whose dramatic work never much impressed me, incidentally: Rex Harrison, Buddy Hackett and (as much as I absolutely love and adore and would marry her) Dolly Parton