[QUOTE=Sal Ammoniac]
Sez who? Anyway, for those who want to read the critique offered by Sibley et al., it’s here.
[/QUOTE]
Oh, I’m not stating it as fact, as you can see. It’s just what I’ve heard.
Anyway, their analysis is absurd. The only evidence I’m using to call it an IBWO is the video I linked to, pointing out the fact that the white is on the trailing edge, and not on the leading edge.
They attempt to refute this with a still photograph (albeit a particularly bad one) of a Mallard. Do they not have video to actually show this “wing twisting” illusion in action? I do not disagree that birds twist their wings in flight. But that is not what is happening here, and David and gang have not provided evidence that this could be the case.
Fig. 2 (F) is irrelevant. That bird is taking flight. Wing positioning during take-off is different from that of an in-flight bird.
They claim that Fig. 3 (A) shows a black trailing edge to the wing. This is a stretch. Sure, if you interpret and resketch the still image the way ol’ David did, it can be seen as a black trailing edge. But look at the video. Watch it again. And again. Where’d the black trailing edge go?
It is also quite silly that they dismiss the white on the bird’s back as a video artifact, but maintain that the black streak you see is a black trailing edge. They are choosing which evidence to accept in order to support their opinion.
But shit, everyone knew that the first people to challenge the evidence would get published in Science, so who wouldn’t give it a decent go?
I’m not even saying that this is definitely an IBWO. But, the evidence points to it being so, and the challenges are weak at best.
Anyway, I have a paper to finish, so I couldn’t look at all of their points. Maybe when I’m done.