One, ‘real’ lightsabers are a bit ‘sticky’ - you can’t slide one lightsaber down the blade of another, even if they hit at an angle. I am doubtful that combat with plastic replicas can replicate that attribute of proper lightsaber combat.
And secondly and most importantly - it’s not sudden death! You can thwack your opponent in the side of the head twice and still lose! That’s absurd! There’s not a single instance in the theatrical canon of a person taking a strike to any part of their body and winning the combat. Surviving, yes. Winning, no.
That was my thought, as well. When Episode V came out, the local paper had an article about the guy who taught and choreographed the fencing. Basically, he was an expert in several sword styles and was leaning heavily on Kendo for the Star Wars stuff.
It seems to me that, if the French made their ‘new’ sport into an exhibition piece at their olympics (like Australia making trampoline-jumping their summer exhibition piece) they’d end up getting rather overshadowed by veteran Dan-level Kendo-ka adapting their bouts to fit the French time and point systems.
–G!
I think maybe the same guy was later featured – perhaps just an updated article – when Conan came out a couple years later.