This looks to be the sort of result I would expect from a mild media-based poll, following such a disastrous election cycle.
The members of the party that lost, especially in the way that they did, would be expected to say that their leadership was out of touch. That, or that they would follow the “it’s all a vile plot by the evil media” route, that some people choose instead.
My own opinion is that they are probably right, though not in any of the ways that each party’s opponents wish that they were. There is no indication that the people who support either Democrats or Republicans, think that the OTHER party is MORE in touch with the people than their own party is. And that fits with the election of a person who both party leaderships reviled, as the President.
What I have seen for a long time now, is that lots of people are unhappy, and both parties have tried to tap into that, but what they each came up with to resolve that unhappiness, has been either ineffective, entirely off target, or directly and abominably destructive. Hence these results.
The health care mess is probably the easiest issue to look at for illumination. To begin with, both party’s seem to have forgotten that the health care issue started out as a secondary indicator of problems in the US, rather than being directly a problem. The cost of living went up dramatically, and employers dealt with competition and profit pressure by cutting benefits and raising employee share of the burden. Neither party attempted to do anything directly about that, and the Republicans declared that nothing at all should be done about health care. (They STILL think nothing should be done, as is evidenced by the fact that they did nothing at all to prepare what to replace the ACA with for the 8 years they spent venting against it). The Democrats decision to GO with the ACA, which again did little to reduce health costs, and nothing to address falling wages and retreating employer benefits, and even made sure that anyone who couldn’t afford insurance would be punished for being underpaid, showed how out of touch with reality THEY were.
Ironically, the Great Wall of Trump may prove to be the ACA of the GOP. It will cost Americans a great deal of money, and although it is popular with some anxious people, it is ALSO designed to address something which is really only an indirect problem for most Americans. We aren’t underpaid and overworked with no benefits , because illegals are taking our jobs. And our cost of living isn’t higher than it should be, because there’s a relative tiny number of people sneaking across the desert. But the Republicans, and Trump especially, have turned the idea of the wall into a symbol for Americans to start demanding that their needs be attended to. When the thing is built, and the bills for it start to roll in, and Americans start to realize that it was never going to address ANY of the real problems they face, there will be the same shift of anger that we have seen with the Democrats objecting to the relatively ineffective ACA.
Right now, the Republicans aree seen to be more in touch by THEIR followers, because they are angry and venting, and so are the people who elected them. But that is likely to change, as their followers SLOWLY catch on to the fact that the solutions that the GOP are going to enact, wont actually solve anything either.
If the Democrats are ready with a real alternative by then (no sign yet that they are even thinking about it), then they could clean up. Otherwise, we’re likely to see more of the same all-tumult, no-fixes stuff that we have for the last three decades, for the next one as well.