Digital Keyboard recommendations, please.

I am sorely missing my piano and would like to buy a digital piano. I don’t want to spend more than about $300-$400. I’ve narrowed my search down to a few and was wondering if anyone could offer some imput.

Casio WK-1630

Yamaha DGX-202

There is a Yamaha DGX-200 at the local Best Buy. For kids like me who are impatient, that is pretty tempting - and despite searching for about an hour online, I can not figure out what the difference is between the 202 and the 200. Anyone have any idea?

I’m open to other suggestions - and online sites you’ve tried that you trust. Thank you for the help!

Tibs.

For the $300-$400 dollar range, you’re not going to get an instrument with weighted keys (ie, feels like a piano). Maybe this is no big deal to you, but unless the specs say “weighted keys,” you’re just going to get light keys with no weight or resistance.

As for the difference between the two Yamaha keyboards, from the Yamaha website, here are things they say the 202 has that they don’t mention about the 200:

32 notes of polyphony - since they don’t say anything about the 200, I’d imagine it may have 16 notes of polyphony. Could be an issue if you want to pedal anything.

MIDI IN/OUT connectors and is General MIDI (GM) and XG Lite compatible, critical for computer use - now, it does say the 200 can be connected to the computer, but I’m suspicious about the fact that it doesn’t mention MIDI in/out for it. If you’re not concerned with computer hookups, don’t worry about this though.

Something like this would give you a much more real piano feel, but it doesn’t come with onboard sounds, speakers, a stand, and that sort of thing. Much more of a hastle, but with this one at $230 on sale, I’d imagine your total cost’d be somewhere around $800 (for example, you’d need something like this as a sound source, maybe this as a speaker, and then probably a $40-50 dollar keyboard stand (which you’d need with the other one too, unless you wanted to just put it on a table) and maybe the same amount in cables.

So, it all depends on what you want. If you’re fine with a non-weighted, very portable and self-contained keyboard, I’d go with the Yamaha 202. Be sure you know you’re ok with non-weighted though. $300-400 is a lot to waste on something you won’t be happy with.

The DGX-200 also has 32 notes of polyphony according to all other sites I’ve seen - and I could have sworn the MIDI IN/OUT as well. I pulled up sites that had specs and cropped my screens so that I had them side by side - one with the 202 specs and one with 200 specs. I may have to do that again to double check. I appreciate your leg work, Eonwe!

The weighted keys may bother me - I’ve only ever played on a true piano. The only thing I can do is go to Best Buy and see how the 200 and the Casio feel. Maybe I’ll go do that today.

Thank you for the good tips!

Tibs.

      • For making music cheaply a MIDI controller is better, but you have to connect it to a computer or an external MIDI module.
  • Also having just bought a electronic/MIDI drum set, I can say that it’s fairly common for many standalone devices to not work when connected to a computer. They are general-MIDI compliant, and work perfect when connected to other MIDI instruments and modules, but there’s some issue (radio interference inside the PC case, I am guessing) with many PC soundcards that causes problems. The general “fix” is to buy an external USB MIDI interface. I went looking for info particular to my drums and soundcard, but searching around on the net I have turned up many instances of this phenomenon with many different MIDI instrument and soundcard combinations. <:/

I am going to try adding some kind of electronic shielding to my soundcard today to see if that helps any.
~

Good luck Tib, and let us know. If you have any more questions, definitely ask. While no expert, I have been using electronic equipment semi-professionally for a number of years now.

I went up a step and purchased the Yamaha DGX-500. 88 keys, weighted, sounds just like a freakin’ grand piano. Unreal! Thank you about the tip on the weighted keys - decided to go with that and upgrade.

WOO!!

Tibs.

Excellent! Hope you enjoy it. We’ll be expecting recordings of your work shortly. :wink: