Scott Adams apparently lost his voice about 18 months ago due to a condition called Spasmodic Dysphonia. He recently posted on his blog about how he has partially overcome this condition, which normally is permanently disabling.
That’s the same condition Diane Rheem from NPR suffers from, right? I hope Scott’s doctor told him about her…her voice may not be beautiful, but she can still make her living from it. Hope Scott continues to improve.
Kitten, if you read the blog you will see that this condition is largely psychological. Scott could speak just fine at speaking engagements and the like, and he could sing you a song with no troubles, but he couldn’t talk normally to anyone in a one on one fashion.
I beg to differ; part of the brain shutting down does NOT equate to being a psychological disorder. I work for an ENT practice which has physicians who specialize in spasmodic dysphonia treatment; most of the rest of Scott’s blog regarding how dysphonia works is accurate.
However, do not confuse a neurological or muscular disorder with a psychological one.
That’s because the part of the brain responsible for regular conversational speaking is different from the part of the brain responsible for singing. Kind of like how the severely Parkinsonian patients in Awakenings could not move voluntarily but could still move reflexively – they could catch a ball if you threw it at them and they reacted reflexively, but couldn’t initiate voluntary movement because the substantia nigra, a crucial part of the brain’s system responsible for initiating voluntary movements.