Do the new tobacco warnings violate 1st Amendment rights?

FinnAgain and NotreDame05:

I think your dispute arises from the fact that you’re arguing different things, and I suspect it’s a lawyerese problem.

NotreDame05’s point is correct: we can’t analyze this question by merely pointing out the Commerce Clause.

FinnAgain didn’t mean to say that we could, even though he did. What he intended to say was that we could regulate warning labels because we’ve been doing it forever. He did not intend to say that we can regulate labels solely because of the Commerce Clause.

I think.