Why Bother indeed…
I am a dedicated reader of TLP ever since I stumbled across his blog god knows how, some months ago… and having read many of his recent posts, have grown tired of waiting for new ones and have begun reading from the very beginning, in 2005.
I think it’s safe to assume that he is actually a psychiatrist, yes. Actually his more recent posts are much less directly related to psychiatry in their subject matter, so it’s somewhat understandable that you might suspect he is just posing as one.
However I do think YOU sir are a tad judgmental, beyond your jurisdiction. And let me preface this by saying that I am not trying to sound any more smart than I am, nor do I think TLP does, either. I am actually trying to express something, through the medium of writing yes because how else do you relay a message to be understood remotely? It would basically have to be either an auditory or visual method. So I’m not leaving you a voicemail, I’m writing the message. Forgive me, overlord…
My criticism of how you are coming off is that you read one post and decided to pass all these judgments. Note the subtitle of TLP (it’s relevant) – it’s German for “Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.” Think about it (don’t speak).
That article of his that you reviewed is just one sample, for one thing. The significance of a single standalone sample of a whole body of work or as a representation of an individual should be fairly obvious, as not heavily weighted.
Then there’s the title of the blog which you also went ahead and took the liberty to criticize/complain about, as being “unclear”. Maybe you should take a step back and realize first of all that you are not god, nowhere near, even. Everything is a matter of perception. That’s one thing. So what may not be clear to you… you know… It’s clear to me, for instance. The title “The Last Psychiatrist” never confused me one bit. I interpreted it as something along the lines of being the last true psychiatrist left to take his business seriously enough to apply logical thinking. Not literally THE ONLY LAST SOLE individual but at least one among the few remaining contrary to the nonsensical stupid masses, many of which still become psychiatrists or political figures or most anything.
Over the years his subject matter has shifted further from spot-on psychiatry, and I don’t see any reason to believe that the very act of blogging in itself and for a public audience may change a person at least a little bit, in the sense that the blog is an interface which like any other adds another dimension to reality. I mean this loosely… maybe not the person is changed (whatever that would mean) but his habits or interests in blogging… I’m not the most articulate and I can’t explain myself perfectly but hopefully you get my gist (or at least try and not just immediately resort to being a stuck-up asshole).
He does not claim to be a writer, anyway; he claims to be a psychiatrist. So I don’t know why you’ve got to dog on him for that shit. He’s supposed to be writing a book on porn, but plenty of people who are not “writers” write books, simply because they have something to communicate, document, transmit… And you know what? I think he’s a fine writer (like wine). Plus, you’ve got to take into account for any typos or missed apostrophes or whatever your issue with his writing is, that he’s (from what I gather) drunk most of the time, and bitter. But I think what you find wrong with his writing is more the substance, and the presentation. If he’s too verbose and you don’t buy it and it sounds artificial to you, fine. Perhaps you’re just not used to it. I read plenty (well I used to, not crap neither) hence my ability to BASICALLY write I guess, and I thoroughly enjoy TLP’s blog, obviously, I’m starting from the beginning of the archives…
But you know what the main point is that you are way too critical of something or someone you know way too little about, and you’re way too sure and defensive of your ill-informed opinion.
Which actually goes to show that you’re stupid, careless, full of your own shit. Try not hating without sufficient reason. It’s so not worth the energy.
This is why I drink daily and read TLP too.
You CAN know, it is ENTIRELY POSSIBLE, don’t go on making retarded declarations like you do like an ass – whether people stick around reading his blog. First think about how little is actually IMpossible or that we can be POSITIVE is IMPOSSIBLE. That’s next to nothing. Then – THINK, it doesn’t take much. Clearly you aren’t a scientist or anything. There are comments on his blog. Many of them state that they are long-term readers and discuss topics he posted earlier in relation to current ones or similar scenarios – ample indication of people “sticking around” for more.
Cudgel knows what I’m talking about…
If anyone seems disagreeable, you certainly do. Maybe you should bother with a doctor.