Does comedy (generally) lean left

I think the point is that the more fanatic the crowd, he more they take their views excessively seriously, the worse their sense of humor. They cannot laugh at themselves. This is characteristic of extreme right and extreme left. Back in the middle ages when I was in university, the college communist party(!) would publish stuff with a political cartoon or two, and it was painful - they did something fanatical and thought it was funny. (It was not). Same with right wing - we had no problem laughing at Biden eating ice cream or saying “Malarkey” etc., but I don’t see anyone right wing mocking even Trump’s comb-over or his oompa-loompa makeup… let alone his patently obvious shortcomings in everything else. “If you can’t laugh about it, you can’t discuss it rationally”.

You took the words right out of my mouth. If I may take it further, good comedy usually involves some intelligence.

To the OP (or anyone else, for that matter), who would you consider to be a good conservative comedian currently working?

“I was once on a German talk show, and this woman said to me, ‘Mr. Williams, why do you think there is not so much comedy in Germany?’ And I said, 'Did you ever think you killed all the funny people?'” — Robin Williams

I understand that the OP is looking at current comedians, but I’ll mention that Sam Kinison’s shtick was almost completely homophobic, misogynistic, racist, xenophobic, ableist, and [fill in the blank]. Based on interviews with him and the people who knew him, it was all an act for the shock value. But just reading his jokes today would make most people cringe.

OTOH, he was the funniest comic I’ve ever heard…until he began to have even worse substance abuse problems.

The problem is that the OP is looking at current comedians, and what is brought up on the conservative side is decades-old shtick from Andrew Dice Clay and Sam Kinison that is most probably a parody of conservatives.
It is hard to compare current “right vs left” comedy when only one side has examples to look at.

I think he took those words out of Stephen Colbert’s mouth. My memory is that it was from his White House Correspondents Dinner speech.

But I’m now officially old, so I could be misremembering.

I think Bridget Phetasy, a very right-wing US comic, has some stretch. She has a podcast and is a guest for other right-wing comics. I don’t think her jokes are great but some of my relatives and peers at work enjoy her comedy.

I thought the question was more just how politically conservative is the Christian comedy circuit, as opposed to carefully apolitical. Tomlinson has mentioned that you had to work clean including avoiding topics like sex, so that there is a lot of stuff like observational family humor. One of her comedic heroes is the very clean and apolitical standup Brian Regan, who doesn’t appear to work the church circuit regularly regularly but is apparently popular with broadly Christian audiences because of that. I’d imagine the heavy-hitters of that industry probably mostly lean either a little or heavily to the right, but how much overtly political humor makes it onto the stage would be an interesting question to ask. I wouldn’t be surprised either way, but if I had to guess I’d be inclined to think it would be less common. I think church audiences specifically would probably mostly prefer blandly inoffensive to cheerleading edgy.

Taylor told a perfect joke, and if I recall correctly it’s what got her kicked off the Christian circuit.

“I’m like a wild animal in bed…way more afraid of you than you are of me.”

Comedy doesn’t have to lean left. Good comedy is often apolitical. Political comics tend to aim more for clapter which plays well with an audience of like minded individuals but I wouldn’t say it’s good comedy.

Yes it’s a false equivalency. Gutfeld doesn’t have a late night talk show.

Sure, there are plenty of great comics who don’t tend to do political work. My favorite living comic is Mike Birbiglia, who doesn’t focus on politics much on stage. But he’s a liberal. It’s sort of obvious.

I like when comedians get into the nuances of politics - like Gianmarco upthread. He makes no secret of his liberalism but he’s also kinda hard on liberalism.

Then there are comedians like Chris Fleming who are so liberal the jokes can really only be understood by cultural progressives. But the stuff he is making fun of is all deep cut progressive stuff. The liberalism is often the butt of the joke.

There’s a big difference to me between someone who writes bits that come naturally from their political views and people who want to write Political Bits as a Political Comedian. Nobody wants to go to a comedy show and be lectured. I don’t even want to be lectured about stuff I already know.

And that’s why I think John Stewart et al. worked. They always put comedy first.

It is so easy to be the greatest comedian in your time period when you are the only comedian in your time period.

Comedy requires introspection, self awareness, insight, intelligence, emotional intelligence, humility and a willingness to question authority and tradition. Things that the right do not do as well as the left. Like it or not its true.

The babylon bee however can be funny. Thats about the only funny right wing source I’ve seen.

And literally thinking about things from different angles at the same time, that flip of meaning, of understanding, is the kernel of much funny.

Yup people who do that well tend not to be today’s conservatives.

Also - humor is often honed in childhood as a defense against bullies. The bully thinks they are funny by calling someone a name, and others laugh along. No skill development. The bullied who defends with jokes has to be good at it, and the pressure is on to do it well, fast, it saves from getting beat up … not a shock that those consequently well trained to think funny fast continue to take down the bullies of the world.

Whether Gutfeld is a late night host or not, his average viewership is more than The Daily Show and Seth Meyers combined. That’s all that counts. He has right-wing comedians on regularly as guests and also occasionally big names, including Roseanne Barr, Rob Schneider, and Jeff Foxworthy, who get mentioned because all three have had specials on the Fox Nation streaming service.

Right-wing comedians really exist and there are outlets for them. A minority, certainly, but they shouldn’t be discounted or dismissed in terms of national cultural importance.

I don’t know. I explained that the only political comedians who come across my feeds are left. I’m unwilling to google “right-wing comedians” because I don’t want to bring the algorithm to my attention. And I didn’t want to declare that there weren’t any because I figured there has to be.

I don’t see much of Foxworthy anymore. Does he actually do comedy now that pertains to the Conservative movement? Barr and Schneider seem to focus on nasty schoolyard barbs (punching down, so to speak) rather than humorous takes of current events. Am I wrong about that?

No clue. I don’t watch right-wing comics normally.* I do keep an eye on what the larger genre is like.

The good news is that it’s much, much more diverse than ever. Comics from every ethnicity, every stop on the LGTBQ spectrum, every notch on the neurodiversity spectrum, every skin color, every religion, every age group, are finding places especially on the internet and doing comedy on what is very personal to them as a way of introducing themselves and leading people on to their broader comedy. It would be extremely odd if that didn’t include rightists.

*The Tom Brady roast featured multiple right-wing comics including Tony Hinchcliffe. But also many left-wing comics. It’s a good intro to a variety of styles and viewpoints. My personal opinion was that the quality ranged from terrific to execrable, but all comedy is personal.

They regularly had Fox News on in the breakroom where I used to work, so I was occasionally subjected to Gutfeld. And I admit, he elicited a chuckle from me every now and then. But you laugh at a Gutfeld joke for the same reason you laugh at a Family Guy gag, not because it’s particularly funny or clever, but more out of a sense of shock that “Whoa! I can’t believe they went there.”