Does comedy (generally) lean left

I get a lot of comedy posts washing past my Instagram and Facebook feeds. Of the ones that delve into politics, almost all of them make fun of the right.

There are notable exceptions Dennis Miller, Ray Steven, Shane Gillis, maybe bill Burr - though he is apolitical. But I’m talking about regular comics who are currently working comedy clubs. A bit will open with something like, “Boy those MAGAS are idiots…or Trump is…”. Which is OK I guess, comedy can be edgy but there seems to be a presumption that they are playing to a left-leaning crowd.

And I realize it might be the algorithm feeding me that stuff, that’s what’s prompting this query. (I didn’t want to search for MAGA comics to skew that part of the algorithm to me)

So, does funny lean left? Do MAGAs go to comedy clubs?

I think it is more a case of “punching up” vs “punching down”.

Yep. Oppression isn’t funny.

Explain, as it relates to this thread?

Also, they make fun of Trump because he’s in power, but lots of comedians made fun of Biden when he was president.

But, yeah, I’d say most comedians, at least famous ones, lean left.

As Czarcasm said, punching down. Right wing “comedians” mock/attack/make fun of those “below” them. Not all, but a great number.

Right-wing comics have a large online following. Tony Hinchcliff is a big name. When Doug Chapelle got into trouble recently it was for quoting a Hinchcliff joke word for word but substituting Charlie Kirk for George Floyd in the punchline. Greg Gutfield’s tv show gets the highest ratings of any late night show, although that’s a function of being on at 10 pm when more people are watching.

There is a huge Christian comedy circuit almost invisible to regular comedy fans. Taylor Tomlinson did church gigs almost exclusively until she decided to break out and go national. I don’t know how political they are.

Comedy clubs have dwindled from their peak and now are down to about 1000. Some fraction of them have to cater to local preferences; I’m sure that right-wing comics can find a circuit even if they don’t break out nationally with political material.

Otherwise, comedy since Lenny Bruce and Mort Sahl reinvented the field of stand-up has been mostly left-leaning. Clinton gave them plenty of jokes but national politics since Nixon has been an easy target. There have been too many years when comedy was the only relief available.

I don’t know the American comedy scene very well, but from my German perspective, let’s get it out of the way: conservative or even right-wing comedy just isn’t funny. Bigots don’t have good jokes. As others have said, only punching down on marginalized people and good causes.

But their bigoted audiences think that stuff is funny as hell. So those “comedians” are certainly getting lots of laughs and clicks and gigs from their chosen audience.

IOW …

Assholes of a feather flock together.

Exactly. Several years ago FOX News tried a “comedy” show of the “Daily Show” type and it bombed. I watched one episode out of curiosity. It was awful. It’s funny to make sport of rich fat cats and their bought-and-paid-for political cronies. It isn’t funny to make jokes about poor people, as FOX quickly found out.

One of the funniest things I’ve ever seen was a montage of typical FOX talking heads spewing their usual crapola with a laugh track dubbed in. It was hilarious.

The explanation for the failure of the Fox News show and other conservative comedy that I found most compelling is that they put the message subordinate to the comedy. Liberal comedians seem to do that less. The Daily Show, for example, had no trouble taking the piss out of Democrats when they did something mockworthy. I follow a lot of comedians who swing liberal, but their liberalism isn’t the point of the set. They are comedians who happen to be liberal.

And another crucial difference: the liberal comedians also make fun of and take up to task liberal politicians, if they have behaved accordingly. Rarely seen the other way round.

Rarely is being generous, closer to never.

Yes. I don’t follow much conservative comedy but it seems more mentally rigid to me and afraid to criticize itself. And it’s not really taking risks with its audience.

I know so many great liberal comedians who enjoy messing with their liberal audiences. (Gianmarco Soresi for example.)

I don’t often agree with Bill Burr but I think he’s pretty funny. I think it’s because he’s not precious about his ideas.

I remember Rush Limbaugh did some song parodies, most were of the punching down type, but the lamest ones were “songs” that were really just neocon talking points “sung” atonally, with absolutely no lilt or melody. It sounded so desperate, so didactic, so obvious.

I don’t have a lot of conservative friends, but one thing they have in common is that they cannot take a joke, and most of what they find funny has a mean streak to it (eg ‘punching down’). If you scale that up, it could explain why comedy seems to lean left.

Succinct.

Nitpick: It’s Dave.

I just recently discovered him! Hilarious!!

…

To answer the OP: you ever hear the expression that “truth has a liberal bias”? The best comedy has an element of truth to it. Ergo, good comedy often has a liberal bias.

Taylor’s politics are pretty openly on the left side of the spectrum. For example:

I generally agree but some comedians have made it big based primarily on punching down, or at least they’ve done so in the recent past. The most notable example I can think of is Andrew Dice Clay, who went on stage portraying a character (sort of like how Paul Reubens would become Peewee Herman on stage doing standup; a total fictional character).

Funny enough, Clay (whose real name is Andrew Clay Silverstein) doesn’t speak openly about his actual politics. However, he absolutely loathes Donald Trump (who he frequently calls “Donny”), has publicly said that Trump is the living embodiment of the “Dice” character he used to play on stage to be deliberately offensive, and was once a contestant on The Celebrity Apprentice but was the first to go because he got into a fight with Trump on camera.

Regardless of his actual beliefs, the misogynistic, disgusting stereotype he played in the late 80s/early 90s bore a lot of resemblance to many modern-day real life right-wing shock commentators, and many of his fans agreed with the views of his awful character.

Wow. Brain Fart City.