does this bill violate privacy? I think it does, what do you think?

[netscape_6]

http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1104_2-1019811.html?tag=fdfeed

Seltzer said the provision for ISPs to cooperate with police and copyright holders is particularly troubling from a privacy standpoint. “That would probably authorize them to tell ISPs, ‘You also need to give information on users to the RIAA (the Recording Industry Association of America) whenever they ask,’” she said.

if true this be a big stab in eye of privacy.

Does this bill hurt privacy too much to be worth it? I think so. What would prevent the RIAA from using this to look for legal (noncopy right infringment) things to pick off some of the indie compititon?

[netscape_6]

:smack: look for legal should be look for illegal

[tracer]

So … would this stand up to a 4th Amendment challenge in Federal court? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?