[QUOTE=e-logic]
the question remains… why single out soldiers? if a judge wore his robes to a wedding it would be daft, likewise a soldier who wears his dress uniform to a social (non-military) event.
[/QUOTE]
The difference is that judges’ robes [ceremonial wear], doctors’ scrubs [work wear], BDUs [work wear] are all not designed as formal wear.
Military formal dress is just that, formal dress. Clothing meant to be worn for formal occasions, both at social functions and official events. The level of dress ranges from the suit-and-tie equivelent to the full blown mess-dress [tux-level].
A judge’s robes are ceremonial robes, they are meant to be worn in court as part of a specific ceremony. If judges had a traditional “formal dress” outfit then by all means they should be free to wear it at appropriately formal occasions.
A doctor’s scrubs are work-wear. They are meant as a functional outfit to be worn at work. If doctor’s had a similiar “formal dress” then sure, it would be appropriate to wear it. They don’t. The exception is of course the Surgeon General who -does- have a official “formal dress.”
BDUs as I stated, are work-wear and should only be worn during, going to, or coming from work. As I stated before, were I in the bar I would have asked for an explanation as to why the member was still in BDUs.
Police, and certain other professions also have designated formal wear and it is of course appropriate to wear for formal occasions.
The clergy, on the other hand, like the judges have ceremonial wear, meant for wear while carrying out certain functions [the full regalia]. Some sects also have their version of “formal dress” and “casual dress” which are of course appropriate in the appropriate setting.
If you’re annoyed that only certain professions have designated “formal dress” then perhaps you should lobby to have your own equivlent created [then wait a few hundred years for the tradition to catch on].
A service member wearing mess dress to a wedding instead of a tux is no more innappropriate then a women wearing a pant-suit instead of a dress. As long as the level of dress [on a casual to formal scale] is appropriate to the event then the dress is appropriate.