Hee. Thanks for giving me something to do during class today.
I had trouble deciding on a leader - I’m not especially fond of Cap and, as someone above noted, a little dissention in the ranks makes for good drama. And I don’t think I want Superman on this…so who? I think I might just let Wonder Woman double up the Brawn and Leader roles. As princess of the Amazon nation, she must have been trained to lead, yes? She won’t need to be controlled like Hulk would, and that lasso could probably come in handy sometimes.
Magician: Zatanna. I figure you need a true magic-user on your team for those enemies, like Superman, who are nigh-invulnerable to just about anything but magic. As noted below, she’s a cool underused character with a good weakness. I briefly considered John Constantine, but he’s not much of a team player. Oh, and I think we’ll be approaching Tim Hunter with an option to join once he grows up.
Mentalist: Jean Grey. One of the most powerful telepaths out there, plus serious telekinesis ability.
Cosmic: Green Lantern. As already noted, Silver Surfer’s a bit unapproachable. And the power ring is an incredibly versatile weapon, assuming we have a suitably inventive GL.
Detective: Nightwing. Almost the equal of his mentor, and a better team player. Plus I figure he can call in Oracle or Bats himself or the rest of the Gotham clan for backup occasionally.
Stealth: I was gonna go with Nightcrawler until Saltire pointed out that Shadowcat is really the better choice. I really love Kurt, though, so maybe we’ll keep him on reserve. He’s a priest, so maybe he can ask God to smite our enemies if all else fails.
Speed: Flash. Not only is he the certified Fastest Man Alive, but he can also fill the role of Guy Who Makes Smartass Comments. Every team needs one.
Scientist: Spiderman. Okay, maybe not strictly speaking the best for the Scientist role, but he’s competent with science and gadgets and he’s got plenty of other talents to recommend him. I briefly considered Beast for this role, but cutting Nightcrawler means Spidey’s agility will be even more useful. Plus, he can help Flash out in the Witty Comments department.
Psycho Broody Loose Cannon: Wolverine. Better for teamwork purposes than Batman, plus the admantium claws should get him in on sheer coolness factor alone.
Useless Power Guy: Superfriends-incarnation Aquaman. Good for comedy purposes, plus he’s got a fairly snazzy outfit.
Besides that, I can’t believe all of you have left out two other vital roles…
Cute Kid: You know you’ve got to have one. But who? I thought Robin at first, but we’ve got Nightwing already, and Shadowcat’s got the hacker skills covered. Impulse? Troia? Arrowette? Bring in Tim Hunter early? I haven’t been able to decide, and so I leave it up to more dedicated comic book geeks than I. What do you guys think?
Animal Mascot: I’m going with Barnabas from Sandman. No actual powers, but hey, a talking dog might come in handy sometime. Need to get inside a heavily guarded compound? Send Barnabas out to engage the head goon in conversation, and while they’re all going, “Holy shit! A talking dog!” Dick and Kitty are sneaking in the back. Plus, being pals with the Endless has got to be useful, and this way I get to bring them all in for cameos.