I looked into this regarding gaining American citizenship and what I found is that if you become an American through marriage you get to keep your Dutch citizenship, but not if you don’t.
However, unless I’m mistaken you can pretty much always return to Holland if you were born Dutch even if you no longer have the citizenship and then you can re-apply for Dutch citizenship after a while. You’ll have to give up your other one at that point, though.
So how would they know? I suppose if they find out later, you have violated your bail condition by failing to surrender it…
Hmmm… I’m pretty sure when I was applying a few years ago it only asked about other citizenships, no qualifying date. Is that recent?
As for the OP, isn’t the answer that you always were an Irish citizen? Or are you “becoming” one when you apply for a passport? I assume the Dutch government attitude is “you left Holland and became a citizen of your new country, so now you don’t belong here”? Not sure if that would apply if you always were an Irish citizen.
Also, is that Dutch provision still applied? I’ve seen similar discussions about US citizenship, and generally the rule seems to be now that despite rules that originally did not really allow dual citizenship when naturalized, the US nowadays does not seem to care, you remain American unless you specifically renounce their citizenship.
From the looks of it, The Netherlands is pretty strict.
But yes, it does look like I am already Irish and in that case the Dutch government is fine with it. The Irish embassy got back to me and they will send me application forms and information about getting a passport.
It’s funny how I never knew about this. My parents always told me I am not Irish because I was simply born there and we moved away (they are not Irish).
One governing body that links my University to the Government mentions my 2nd nationality in my profile but I figured that was a mistake because I was born there. They might have been onto something.
I am out of the country for the next 1,5 months so I will wait with applying until I get back but I’ll keep you updated.
All of my grandparents were born in England, so if I jump through enough hoops I can get ‘indefinite leave to remain’ (landed immigrant status) based on my UK ancestry. I’d still have to live there for five years and go through the other steps to become a UK citizen and get a UK passport. No grandparents were born in Northern Ireland, so I can’t claim Irish citizenship as well as (or instead of?) UK citizenship. No quick route to a second passport for me…
At some point they’re likely to ask - you’e going to have to sign a form somewhere along the way stating your nationality, or something of the kind. (E.g. when you next renew your passport.) So if you’re going down this road you need to be willing to do more than just “don’t tell”. You need to be willing, when the time comes, to lie.
And, whether before or after you get to the point of lying, you also face the risk that at some point they will find out, through some bureaucratic process or other. Again, if you’re going down this road, you need to decide at the outset that you’re willing to face that risk.
Finally, you may need to clarify one thing. In some countries, citizenship law is such that, if you take steps to acquire another citizenship, then the government may deprive you of your first citizenship. But the more usual model is that your own action in taking out a new citizenship is, in itself, a renunciation of your existing citizehship. So, if it all comes to light after (say) twelve years, the position is not that after twelve years of dual citizenship you may now lose your first citizenship (but possibly you can intercede with the government not to do this). The position is likely to be that you haven’t been a citizen of your home country for the past 12 years, and this is only now coming to light. There may or may not be a procedure by which you can apply to have your citizenship restored, but you’ll be starting from the position of not having been a citizen for the past 12 years, and you may have to face awkward questions about the answers you gave to questions four years ago, when you renewed the passport that you weren’t entitled to.
This can get messy, is what I’m saying. The ethics of deceiving people aside, a strategy which depends on information not coming to light is always risky, and the longer you persist in the strategy the bigger the mess if it does become unstuck.
Even my grandparents & parents were/are Dutch & English, so clearly it is not quite as difficult as all that. The forms I encounter only ever ask “nationality” - I choose one. That’s not a lie. They don’t ask you to list all of you nationalities.
The last time I applied for a Dutch passport I was living in de UK and had to get my passport in the Hague. I asked the official there if I should list my UK citizenship, they just said it was up to me. I think I might’ve asked that when I immigrated back to the Netherlands, too. Nobody has ever said I should honestly list all my nationalities.
I get the idea, but my point is that in practice it really doesn’t matter, nobody actually cares and there is no mechanism to find out. It’s just populist tough talk on discouraging dual nationalities, nothing more.
This is obviously going to depend on the precise rules, as well as on the attitude, of the particular countries concerned. Lots of countries have no problem at all with dual nationality, of course. And, of those that do, most are unconcerned about dual nationality that arises simply from the circumstances of your birth, or that is conferred on you as a incident of marrying someone. What bother them is when somebody actively pursues naturalisation in another country. As we have already seen in this thread, Rama was born an Irish citizen. She has never, until now, applied for an Irish passport or (I assume) exercised other incidents of her Irish citizenship, but she has always been an Irish citizen. The Netherlands government has no problem with this, and there is no problem if she now applies for the Irish passport to which she has always been entitled.
And some countries require, when you apply for naturalisation, that you should explicitly renounce your existing allegiance, or that you take steps to renounce it with your own government. I suspect if a Netherlands citizen applied for naturalisation in such a country, the chances of the Netherlands government getting to hear of it would be non-trivial.
So, it crucially depends on the laws and practices of the two countries involved.