MilliCal, our 6-year-old, insisted on watching this series. I agreed, figuring it was harmless.
I have to admit, up front, that I’m a Warner Brothers cartoon lover, and that, in my opinion, the greatest cartoons are the ones made by Chuck Jones in the early 1950s. Rannit Fire; Rabbit Seasoning; Duck, Rabbit, Duck; One Froggy Evening; Duck Amuck No one has matched these for comic presentation or timing. Ultra-sophisticated (“Shoot me again, I enjoy it! I love the smell of burnt feathers and gunpowder and cordite!”).
Nevertheless, although lots of people enjoy them, I have to admit that I’ve never liked the “Duck Dodgers” cartoons, even when Jones was doing them. I suppose the fact that they were poking fun at a genre that was even then decades old – sort of shooting at a (forgive me) sitting duck – contributed to that. They seemed pretty irrelevant. So I didn’t expect much from a Duck Dodgers series done by someone else.
Face it, the “new” Warners cartoons don’t stand up to the old ones. I eagerly went to see “Daffy Duck’s Quackbusters” when it first came out. Dull, uninspired writing and direction. No real parody of “Ghostbusters”, as the title implies. The damned thing just wasn’t funny. And the ones that followed were worse.
It didn’t have to be that way. Cartoons aren’t really supposed to be inoffensive pablum meant to appeal to the lowest common denominator. Animation critic Richard Thompson, writing in 1980, suggested an up-to-date Daffy cartoon:
This is the kinda thing we werem’t getting, and I didn’t expect better of the current incarnation of DD. So I watched a bit of it, and wasn’t impressed. They’re still using Chuck Jones’ characters. They’ve added some androids and a Martian Queen. Ho Hum.
And then, Dodgers quiets cadet Porky Pig’s stuttering conniption fit with a cool:
“Find your thenter, Honey-Baked.”
And I lost it. For the first time in years – decades, maybe, I laughed at a new Daffy Duck cartoon.
Most of the cartoon continued to be the same derivative stuff, but every now and again they’d toss out some treat, some witty bit of writing to us hard-core fans and SF buffs to keep us happy.
Porky: Fire! Trust your feelings!
Duck Dodgers: Thanth, but I think I’ll use this expensing Tagrgeting Computer we’ve got.
Or… Duck Dodgers going on at length about the toupee that he’s got, "…actually, it’s a hair weave,’’ a la Shatner.
I think I’ll watch a few more of these.