jarbaby, I learned to knit a few years ago. I’m self taught, and started on scarves, too. I’m left handed as well, and no, it didn’t help. Luckily (for me, I mean), I’m ambi-sinister, so I managed to knit right handed, after giving up trying to switch the directions around.
Here’s what I can tell you. The first, say, 30 rows of knitting I did were painful. I can’t tell you how long it took me to get the first row then. But, once I had done it a few times, something clicked, and it became really easy.
I remember being confused by the same instructions that are causing you grief. It think you may be holding the yarn backwards (yeah, I know, that’s a big help, isn’t it?). Do you have to fight with it to get a stitch done? I mean, does it take, like, 30 seconds to add a stitch, or do they flow along naturally?
I’m going to teach my wife to knit, anyway, so I’ll give it a try tonight and see if I can remember what I did wrong. I’ll also see if the books think I knit left handed or right handed-that will tell me if I should be giving out knitting advice (with any luck, I knit left handed, and can make one of the right-handed oppressors suffer for a change).
But, even if it turns out that I can’t help, take heart. It seems to just come to people, after they’ve played with it for a while.