[QUOTE=RickJay]
That is in fact precisely what I am saying.
If you sent 300,000 soldiers, the effect would be to give you twice the manpower to stop the insurgency, and to give Iraqis twice the reason to join the insurgency. The assumption being made here appears to be that the Iraqis can be bought off with paved roads and cosnsitent electrical service. I suppose that’s true for some folks, but the truth is that what a great deal of Iraqis want more than anything is for the Americans to leave. The ones who MOST want them to leave are those who’ve had relatives and friends killed by the Americans, which is now quite a few people.
I mean, ask yourself honestly; if a foreign power invaded your country and a bomb dropped by one of their planes killed your child, would you be okay with them occupying your country just so long as the utilities seems to work okay? I don’t know about you guys, but as for me, it would become my life’s mission to kill as many cmembers of that army as I possibly could. And there’d be a lot more people in that position if you sent in another five divisions or so.
Why would you think this? The occupation will end only when it no longer suits the needs of the United States to occupy Iraq; that’s not necessarily going to end when, if ever, the insurgency is quelled.
[/QUOTE]
The insurgency can depend on two types of support. There is active support coming from citizens who believe in their cause and assist them with money and supplies and provide them facilities such as safe houses and garages in which to build bombs.
There is also passive support from people who don’t report suspicious activity; and basically keep their heads down and try not to get involved. I think it is almost certain that this group is larger than the first. This group is essentially the swing voter in the equation and they most certainly can be bought off with paved roads and sewer systems. One has to remember that the Hussein regime did not have much legitimacy and there were plenty of people who were glad to see him go. The support of these people was also up for grabs and it was the US’ to lose, which it did.
Things like running water, electricity and open schools give a government legitimacy. Insurgencies feed on chaos and they can point to the lack of infrastructure as sign that the current government does not have legitimacy.
It is also important to remember that the people who are suffering the most from insurgent attacks are Iraqi civilians. While many people would oppose a foreign invading army, that does not necessarily mean they are going to support an opposition that regularly detonates car bombs in the middle of crowded cities slaughtering passersby.
Also, because the US invaded with less troops than the initial war plans called for, US forces raced to Baghdad and left behind huge pockets of troops. When the government of Hussein collapsed, these troops melted away and reappeared as insurgents later on. It is no accident that the cities that the US bypassed like Fallujah are the same places where the insurgency has been able to establish base of operations.
There was a great article in Atlantic Monthly last year called Blind into Baghdad that detailed the cuts Rumsfeld made to troop levels prior to the invasion. There were US military officers who predicted the results we now have.