I don’t see where *paying * for something you stole is a punishment. Then it just becomes a credit purchase. Probation does sound a little light - like little more than “time out” for adults. Maybe they apologized and promised never to steal again or somthing. :rolleyes:
We don’t know the whole story, of course. I sure don’t. Paul Reed Smith Guitars is a small firm, though, and perhaps Lanahan is a valued employee. Something like, “Yes, he’s a junkie and a thief, but he’s the best luthier I’ve got.”