Experimental/Pioneering Cosmetic Surgery

I imagine if you’re pioneering a new technique for medical surgery, you would practice on animals first. Then you would offer the surgery to people who were desperately ill and had no viable alternatives. Then - as the surgery itself gets credibility and you build up your own expertise - you would gradually expand to people with more and more benign conditions. Question is how this applies to cosmetic surgery.

On the one hand, I would think that animals are much more similar to people as regards to the functioning of internal organs than they are as to cosmetics. And at the same time, I would think the level of precision required for cosmetic surgery to be a success is much higher than the level required for treatment of medical conditions - the difference being that in the latter case it’s generally replacing/repairing a malfunctioning organ while in the former case it’s just about improving a natural appearance. So the question is about how these techniques are pioneered in the case of cosmetic surgery.

Of course, the above applies most strongly in cases where people are just trying to improve an appearance that’s already within the bounds of “normal”. If you have someone whose appearance was severely disfigured by some accident or fire, then there might be more room to experiment since anything might be an improvement. So I guess it’s possible that most cosmetic surgery techniques are outgrowths of techniques which were originally pioneered on severely disfigured people and later expanded to more ordinary people. But I don’t know if this is actually the case.

I also wonder about the training/experience of individual doctors. Suppose some doctor somewhere pioneers a new technique. And you’re some highly successful surgeon with years of experience with all sorts of other techniques but have obviously never done this one. How do you get in on it? Do you just read up on it, or attend some seminar where it’s described? Or do you actually intern and/or participate in some actual surgery under the supervision of the guy who invented it? This applies to ordinary surgery too, but ISTM - and I could be wrong here - that new techniques are more commonly being invented in the cosmetic surgery field, and also, again, that the need for this type of surgery is frequently lower than for other types of surgery, such that the risk/reward ratio of undergoing the surgery at the hands of a guy who never did it before might be different.

You’ve never seen those photos of celebrity cosmetic surgeries gone bad?

Modern plastic surgery techniques originated in Britain after WW1. there was no shortage of injured soldiers/sailors/airmen willing to be guinea pigs. the same doctors also worked on airmen disfigured in WW2 and the patients formed their own club called, appropriately enough, the Guinea Pig Club

They also practice on cadavers.

Nor, given OP’s join date, has he likely read Qadgop the Mercotan’s account of (…ahem…) another kind of cosmetic surgery gone bad.

(Said post also [still more …ahem…] includes link to explicit photo, which link is thankfully long defunct. But you can see the same thing here as well if you dare to look.)

Are we talking bagel dogs here? (Save me a hyper jump .)

Yes, bagel dogs.

Also I’d bet techniques are often tried on tested on areas of the body where precision is not such a concern first.

For example, you can have liposuction on the under chin and lower cheeks.
It makes sense for this technique to only have become established after years of performing liposuction on parts of the body where precision is not a huge concern, and the gradual refining of techniques that has occurred during that time.