FAA issues nationwide ground stop due to "extraordinary circumstances" (for discussion, not breaking news)

I decided to fly out Monday, since there was nothing today and tomorrow was pricy. With my trip credit it wasn’t bad including hotel. Am in different hotel (long story) until I can check into mine.

Brian

Certainly a lot going on in the cyber-world nowadays. I suppose someone is already writing a book. I suppose I will have to read it.

I just want to point out that I made the preemptive assumption that this system would be a problem two months ago in the Stupid MFers thread.

Note: I know I said “DC area” but at the time the SMART system was only the DC area with plans for wider implementation.

There are reports that semis were told to stop last night. {Warning: foul language in link} Given that this man thinks it might be UFOs, I don’t know how strong a cite he is. But I have seen multiple reports of this, and his video of the truck stop is the best footage.

…except that the US air traffic control system really is ancient and that rickety. And has been for decades.

Did this get posted already? (Sorry, was trapped in the airport all of yesterday so I missed a lot)

Apparently old infrastructure just… couldn’t keep up and crashed. Not a very satisfying explanation. But… takes notes… not a bad way to ask for a cool few billion dollars. Next time my software needs an upgrade, I should just be sure to engineer a national flight stoppage.

Sitting at our gate, about to board in twenty minutes or so. Airport is very crowded but our flight is on time (so far, anyway).

Best of luck!!

How are the passengers and staff holding up? Yesterday everyone was still nice where we were. I imagine folks are getting more frazzled by now?

Looking good. Crowded but no drama so far. There was applause when an earlier flight announced boarding.

Listening to Duffy demand 50B is infuriating yo GTFO with your ransom demands

At least some of y’all are returning from vacay and not heading out best of luck today.

I felt a certain comraderie (sp?) among fellow passengers and the counter agent was quite nice considering what she was dealing with (thus was my rebook)

Brian
Who flies commercially maybe once a year with plenty of gaps.

Thank goodness FAA seems to have restored most of their capacity.

As I suggested upthread, it’ll be a day or 3 to restore airline normalcy after we have FAA normalcy.

To answer a couple questions upthread …

Q: What happens to all the people on the planes when the problem starts?

A:
If an airport can’t launch for whatever reason, but can land planes, real quick every gate is filled and airplanes start piling up in the holding areas and eventually taxiways get filled too. Each airport has a playbook on which taxiways to leave free and which to start filling with waiting jets.

It’s real unlikely any airport gets to the point where there’s simply no place to park the next landing plane; there just aren’t that many inbounds relative to the size of the airport.

The sooner the airline(s) admit defeat and get the airplanes waiting to depart deboarded the better. Once any airplane at a gate is emptied of passengers and FAs, the pilots can taxi it off the gate and into some holding / parking space somewhere. Where they may be left sitting for hours. But that frees the very valuable gate to accommodate a landed airplane. Which will pull in, deboard passengers and FAs, then also move off to wherever to accommodate another landed airplane. Eventually everybody is deboarded. Eventually.

Real quick the process begins to resemble solving this puzzle but with 100 or 200 pieces and still just one empty space.

There are regulations, so called “tarmac delay rules” requiring passengers be deboarded within X hours of landing. The details get deep quickly. But there’s also a Force Majeure clause. When it’s physically impossible, it’s physically impossible and the play clock stops running.

The way all this can turn into a real nightmare is when airline management, relying on what news is dribbling out from FAA (or the weather people), continues to hold out the hope of getting the whole machine moving again, albeit a couple hours late. Cancelling everything is an expensive nightmare that can’t be undone once decided. So they have a strong incentive to sit tight and hope the problem clears in 1 or 2 hours and they can launch the already boarded airplanes, albeit late.

The one fact everyone wants to know: “When will this end?” is the single most unknowable fact while the problem is still being worked.




Q: How will / can passengers be re-accomodated after a mass disruption?

A:
Short answer: They can’t.

Long answer: They can’t on any reasonable timeline. It’ll take a day or two for the airlines to be operating their full schedule. When FAA finally gives the green light too many planes and crews are not where they were planned to be and getting the whole thing operating normally again takes time to get more and more of their assets in the right places at the right time to resume their spot in the assembly line.

Meanwhile, even if they could magically restore the full schedule the next day, those planes are already booked nearly full, say 90%. So if, e.g., there was one whole day of productivity lost, you’re looking at 10 days to get every one of those displaced butts into a seat going to [wherever].

If you think about it, over the course of a day very close to half the passengers are outbound from home to [wherever] and about half are inbound from [wherever] to home. If it was otherwise, either home would be depopulated pretty quick, or [wherever] would be.

A lot of outbound trips become useless if they can’t be done timely. No point in flying a day late to a business meeting. Nor to a cruise. Same thing starts happening with even hotels. Say you have a reservation for Orlando Disney for Mon-Fri nights. Now you can’t get there until Wed. Even if you have the flex to extend your vacation for Wed-Sun, it’s a good bet the hotel can’t accomodate you; they’re booked pretty full too. Is it still worth going if you still need to check out Sat morning? Maybe not.

The saving grace is that a very large fraction of people who were going outbound during the outage simply cancel their trip and stay home. Very roughly 2/3rds do. Which reduces the people needing to be accomodated by about a third. Of those remaining, some fraction can rent a car and drive home. etc.

My former employer alone moves between half and 3/4ths of a million people per day. It’s one hell of a mess when that many eggs get scrambled at once.

Thanks, the “folks give up and cancel” is a factor that did not occur to me.

There were some empty seats when I booked for Monday, guessing that is normally not a huge travel day.

Brian

But the system is going to be even more overtaxed while recovering from this. If it couldn’t handle the normal load, how will it be able to handle the increased load?

The explanation doesn’t make sense. If it really is due to old infrastructure, why are we going back to full capacity like it couldn’t happen again tomorrow or next week or next month?

It’s not like it was an unusual traffic day. And Thanksgiving travel is coming up in a couple weeks, which would be much worse for air traffic. So, why aren’t officials warning about that if this is such a risk?

And if it was “old copper” or whatever, how does that cascade from wherever the local hardware issue happened to become a nationwide problem?

While full explanations to the public aren’t always possible, something more than “trust us, you can accept our contradictory responses” is warranted.

Apparently the ground stop was just for the IFR (Instrument Flight Rules) system, so VFR (Visual Flight Rules) was still allowed. So as long as the weather is good enough to navigate and avoid mid-airs by looking out the window they could fly. But no flying through or even near clouds.

They would also be limited to below 18,000 ft altitude, and jets get worse mileage the lower they fly. So a private jet might not have the range to get to a planned destination if they fly at 17,000 instead of a more normal 35,000.

This is what happens when you leave our nation’s transportation infrastructure in the capable hands of a plumber with dim wits and an MTV reality show character.

They love Big Brother.

By luck I was on a Southwest flight the day after their Christmas time disaster a few years ago. I had no trouble getting on the flight, and there were even a few empty seats. The airport (Indianapolis) was not all that crowded either. Now that was a problem for just one airline, but I suspect a lot of people cancelled.

Extrapolate this to the entire government. Our government is like a set of fiefdoms in the Holy Roman Empire. They have separate budgets, separate policies, separate systems, and a rotating cast of dukes and princes who likely have the modern technical competence of a duck.

Upgrading from paper to computers (electronic flight slips) in the ATC has been a 43 year process and still isn’t fully complete. Reagan and Austin didn’t get them done until Trump’s current term. Canada did it in 11 years. Still. Eleven years. Best case scenario. For a system that has to be essentially flawless on day one of install and also work flawlessly with non-modernized systems the entire conversion period. With numbers of controllers far below par, overworked, overstressed, and needing to add enormous amounts of training time to their schedules.

This failure is the canary in the coal mine.We lived through it. We might not be so lucky when they replace the canary with a duck.