Well said.
FAA ATC modernization has been an ongoing headache and failure since I was a teen. Various Big Bang projects have been started, encountered insane cost overruns and schedule delays, then been cancelled with nothing to show for it. Over and over.
By the time any smaller project gets installed, most of the hardware it was designed for is already obsolete and replacement parts are quickly becoming unavailable.
Congress always provides too little money too late and has no patience for the overruns and delays that are inherent in any / every IT project anywhere that’s of any serious scope.
Many subsystems of ATC’s total inventory of computers, radars, communications, procedures, software, etc., have been successfully replaced in the last 30-40 years. But there’s still a lot more backlog than there is completed work. And the earliest of those completed projects are themselves now well overdue for replacement / upgrade. Again.
So here we are. No different than we are with the interstate highway system that we could afford to build, but now choose not to be able to afford to maintain. Same with dams. And wastewater treatment systems. It’s somehow easy to appropriate money to build new. But not to maintain, nor to replace worn out with new stuff that may not offer anything other than the ongoing out of sight ought of mind reliability we all crave from our infrastructure.
It’s a legitimately Sisyphean task. Like painting the Golden Gate Bridge, when you get to one end the only sensible thing to do is go right back to the other end and starting painting it anew.
Those kinds of tasks require a mature management process and we do not, and have not had for decades, a mature Federal governance culture to deliver that patient far-sighted and adequately-resourced management.
Certainly all the mismanagement of the trump years, and of the MAGA Congress years have not helped. And of the “Starve the beast” years beginning with St. Ronnie the Senile.
But there’s plenty of blame to be spread across all those 50 years. For once, although trump and his incompetent traitorous thieving cronies are certainly the last ones to touch it, this one really isn’t any more their fault than it’s all their predecessors’ faults too.