That solution presumes the problem has been properly elucidated. That’s a more fundamental issue - if the “problem” being solved is a lie made up for whatever reason, any solution proposed to solve that particular “problem” isn’t going to work. It’s something I have to explain to early career folks a lot - before jumping in to “fix” a problem, you have to know what the actual problem is first, not just go around patching things and possibly exacerbating the problem or creating new issues.
And, yes, the infrastructure is creaky and aging and a complete top to bottom overhaul/replacement is needed, but, as a symptom, that doesn’t seem to fit as a proximate cause for the events of this weekend, given the several different, often contradictory explanations provided by government officials.
I don’t think it’s possible to explain a failure in a single sentence. The Centers are interwoven between themselves and the airports within their sphere of control.
I’m not sure why all the Centers were declared dysfunctional while the local towers were not. We’ve had issues with individual Centers shut down but not all of them. They should operate independently and with redundancy.
In many cases there are Military bases with towers that could be pressed into service if a single Center shuts down. There should be plans in place that utilize existing assets. It’s hard to imagine there isn’t a multiple layer of redundancy. I
I make no comment about whether this has any basis in fact. Not accusing you of fabrication, but we never really know about anything coming out of the regime these days.
But as a long-ago IT guy, I’ll point out that 1000 connections in even 4 seconds is a mere 250 per second. Which is an absolutely trivial amount of traffic that seems woefully inadequate to strain any system, even one that’s already rather heavily loaded.
It wouldn’t be me doing any fabricating, but instead FAA’s Rebecca Guy, who made the claim about the pings. You can find her remarks on this page, which quotes the Wall Street Journal (which I’m not linking as it’s paywalled). The article addresses your point about the ping-frequency Guy noted being trivial:
.
.
Not equivalent. The 2023 ground stop lasted between 60 and 90 minutes by most accounts. In that case the cause wasn’t in dispute–it was a straightforward (but improper) file deletion by a contractor, during a database synchronization process that appears to have been routine.
In addition to the duration difference: the Secretary of Transportation at the time (Pete Buttigieg) made no demands for billions of dollars to be handed over to him.
I’m not saying that it was equivalent, just that it existed. I kept hearing from respectable news sites that it was only the second since 9/11 and had to look it up because it was not memorable. Even so, the right - Trump also tweeted about it - jumped all over it then and are being their usual hypocritical selves now by trying to push off any blame they might have.
Good point–the ‘not since 9/11’ is being talked about a lot, and the 2023 incident should be included. Though it’s fair to mention the duration issue (many hours in both 2001 and 2026; fewer than two in 2023).
There’s no realistic chance of this actually getting better, right? Even with 50 billion dollars, 49.9 billion of it is going to golf courses and revolving doors, and the ATC overhaul will go as well as high speed rail did?
The demand from Sean Duffy, Secretary of Transportation, for fifty billion to fix the air traffic control system is ridiculous. Last year, Congress appropriated $12.5 billion for this and much remains unspent and he hasn’t detailed how the fifty billion would be budgeted. In short, he’s just throwing numbers out there.