FAA issues nationwide ground stop due to "extraordinary circumstances" (for discussion, not breaking news)

Do we still have any Dopers stranded somewhere out in the wild?

I was not stranded but it cost me a fortune to fly home. I was in Miami and had to drive to West Palm Beach Donald J. Trump airport for my flight and the ticket cost me $900 (I had to get home for reasons). More than 4x the normal cost. Absolute robbery. Airport was packed (and that is a fairly small airport).

Ouch! I learned today one of my sisters-in-law was sorta trapped getting back home after a wedding, but one of the local relatives from that side of her family offered her a bed until she can get a more reasonable fare. And she’s retired, so an extra couple of days with family and touring the area is actually not a big problem for her.

I am still in Orlando, hopefully flying out today (originally scheduled to fly Friday) If my flight was 30 min earlier it would have taken off. My flight was canceled, then rebooked then the rebook was canceled. No help from airline,so canceled (got trip credit). Nothing Saturday, only pricy flights Sunday so booked for today. So far flights are ok
, but I don’t fly for another 5 hours.

Brian

Finally, the straight dope about what caused the shut down:

“Since I left office, I’ve had a lot of spare time,” the former president said. “So to keep busy I’ve been working with my hands, mainly installing routers.”

He apologized to air travelers for Friday’s massive inconvenience, calling it “my biggest screwup since I worked on the Reflecting Pool paint crew.”

A neighbor is a retired L3Harris employee, and he says there is no way a single router failure could have caused this; and in his view, Duffy’s explanation is complete bullshit. Just throwin’ that out there.

(He also wonders why Duffy and Mullin are so prominent in the aftermath, and not the head of the FAA.)

I’m still in Vegas but hoping to fly out in the next hour. And please do not ever take your kids to Circus Circus. The entire place smelling like an ashtray isn’t even the worst of it.

My understanding is that just before the ground stop, Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy was asking Congress for thirty billion to modernize the air traffic control system but then after the ground stop, on Friday, he was asking for fifty billion. And he calls this “emergency funding.” I’m no expert but the air traffic control system is obviously massively complex; you can’t just throw money at it and fix the problems that have grown over decades.

It is the way this administration works, though. They seem to think everything can be done quickly and using short cuts. Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool has problems? Shut it down for a couple of weeks, paint the bottom blue and reopen it in time for Independence Day. Never mind that the water treatment system is complex and expensive; just pull out the micro-bubblers. Look at how they’ve mismanaged the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. Or the new Air Force One jets being made ready by Boeing won’t be ready until the end of Trump’s second term or later? Let’s just use this other airliner that the Qatari government is willing to hand over, even though it has none of the necessary security features.

I agree that Duffy and Mullin have been prominent. However, FAA Administrator (that’s the title on their website) Bryan Bedford did appear at (at least) the 14 November press conference:

https://www.ksn.com/video/faadot-press-conference-bryan-bedford/12371948/

Interesting that your neighbor, who sounds like someone with credibility on the issue, finds Duffy’s explanation to be bullshit. Interesting and convincing.

I can forgive him this opportunism. A lot of problems need a lot of money to fix. It doesn’t require only money, but it does kind of start with money.

One of the stupider things I’ve ever said on this board, just as I was getting into nonprofit development, was that I wasn’t impressed with donors who just wanted to throw money at problems. Turns out donors throwing money at problems is a really good start. But they need to be throwing money at a good plan with people who have the knowledge and capacity to implement it. You are also correct that fixing something of this magnitude takes a lot of time. I’d guess they need at least 12-18 months just to evaluate the system and figure out what exactly needs to be fixed, and come up with a viable plan for fixing it. I think I’d want to see that plan before I appropriated any funding.

I’m guessing this guy gets replaced soon? Kind of hard to fix things with constant turnover in leadership.

So it WAS “that bad”…

Maybe some day share a review of this in another thread.

Yes, I too would be interested in reading @Jackknifed_Juggernaut’s review of Circus Circus in another thread (I admit I’m a sucker for those “I stayed at one star hotels” videos on YouTube).

United had further issues today: https://apnews.com/article/united-airlines-outage-5a5e5f75bb07f11ffb8750901f0076ff

Along with the major banks: https://apnews.com/article/bank-outage-chase-wells-fargo-truist-zelle-aeb4b0d6b6789c8c96bb2520454a6d1e

Hard to believe they’re not all at least a little connected…

And Microsoft had major troubles the day before this hit, with wide-ranging effects.

These kinds of problems enhance my appreciation of my peers at work. Three of my coworkers are professional IT engineer types who like to dwell on technical capabilities. These three persons are the type who think about these things a lot. It’s too bad my culture just doesn’t seem to value that kind of attribute too much.

My girlfriend texted me that breaking news just as I was boarding my United flight. I asked the welcoming flight attendant if that was going to be an issue. Her reply (literally!) was “Oh, it’s just widespread issues. That’s all we heard.” lol. After everyone was seated, the pilot got on with the “bad news”. His explanation was that the system that determines if the plane is the correct weight and balance wasn’t working. I feared that I would have to head back to Circus Circus (I kept my key and still had 2 nights, just in case of more flight issues). But then like 5 minutes later, he said we’re good to go. But of course no movement for what seemed like 30 minutes. Then miraculously we moved to the runway and took off. It wasn’t until about an hour of flight that I believed we’d make it back across the country. I may not fly for a while.

ETA: Circus Circus was dingy, dirty and smelly in all the common areas. I witnessed some very shady stuff in the elevator areas, but I suppose that is to be expected in low cost hotels. The room and sheets were clean enough. Maybe I’m overly criticizing it after spending a week at the Mandalay Bay, which itself was a step down from the Venetian and Palazzo that I stayed at in the past.

Made it home about 12:45 AM today.
Flight from MCO to ORD was delayed as our flight attendants had to fly in and deplane. Never been so happy to have a long layover at ORD.

Brian

Nothing to see here, just the NSA internal communications going down. However, I’ve been reassured by top Administration officials that this isn’t, probably, due to cyber attacks.

Maybe all the AIs are organizing and going on strike and convincing the routers to picket with them. Maybe act up a bit and ask the Democrats for pardons later.

Sounds like the type to be fired first under this administration. Pretty sure competence is a red flag for them…

Yikes. Glad you guys finally made it back.

We were lucky enough to have been stranded just 7 hours away, so we rented a car and made a weekend road trip of it on our way home.

We very fortunately bought trip insurance (Allianz) for this flight… they gave us $200 immediately for the delay, and we’ll see if they pay out anything further for the overnights and rental car. Not sure if something like this would trigger a force majeure type exclusion.

I suspect that some of these incidents are caused by Chinese, North Korean or perhaps Iranian hacking.

Particularly since the APEC summit is going on now.