Fantasy Novel Recommendations

Evidently, you all seem to read quite a bit, and have deep opinions on the subject, but I’m a lazy man, and I have to sleep sometime. Who are some of the favorites for Fantasy Novels? I’ve read all of Jordan’s Wheel of Time so far, and I am in the midst of Weis and Hickman’s Deathgate cycle. I have enjoyed all of them, though my standing favorite is Michael Stackpole, even though he killed me with a rather jarring ending of his latest, and now I’m sitting on end waiting for the next installment. I suppose that’s a good thing, at least for his book sales.

Anyway, I have a secondary stack of authors that I can’t seem to get into as well, and after 40-50 pages, I just decide that I don’t care what happens, and start a different author. I try to pick longer sagas, so if I do get involved with the story, I have thousands and thousands of pages to go before I have to say goodbye to the characters. Does anyone have any favorites to recommend? I prefer fantasy over Sci-fi, but I enjoy Sci-fi as well, particularly Larry Niven.

I enjoyed the story of King Arthur, as told in T.H. White’s The Once and Future King and its continuation, The Book of Merlyn. I have met many who would heartily recommend J.R.R. Tolkein’s The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings trilogy. Mark Twain’s A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court is another. Good reading.

Never read T.H. White, I’ll have to look into it.

I’ve read Tolkein and Twain, though it was a long time ago. I definitely enjoyed them, and they probably started me into the fantasy books. I probably prefer Tolkein’s alternate worlds fashion to Twain’s medieval times storytelling, but hey, it’s Tolkein and Twain, how could I pick?

Thanks.

I’ve never considered myself a “fantasy” fan, but picked up a book by Terry Brooks called “Wizard at Large” a few months ago. I’m looking forward to reading the rest of the books in the series.

T.H. White is wonderful; if you enjoy him, you would likely enjoy Stewart. My all-time favorite author of Arthurian fantasy is Mary Stewart. She brings medieval Britain, and the legendary characters, completely to life. Also, there is Jack Whyte’s collection, the Camolud Chronicles, which offers a more feasible, realistic version of King Arthur’s story. I enjoyed the first 2 but got a bit bogged down as they went on, it gets a bit complicated and technical, the characters in the beginning of the saga are more compelling than the later ones.
Other favorite fantasy authors: Ray Bradbury, Orson Scott Card, Robert Heinlein,Connie Willis. Willis’ ‘The Doomsday Book’ (in paperback!) is a splendid read, but with today’s possible bioterrorism goings-on, it is almost too close to truth rather than fiction.

Tad William’s Memory, Thorn and Sorrow is probably one of the most well-constructed fantasy novels I’ve ever read. I highly recommend it. Williams has a talent for incorporating traditional fantasy archetypes (dragon-slaying protagonist, magic sword, “elves,” and so on) without them being cliche or feeling “samey” or unrealistic.

Personal favourites:-

E.R. Eddison, The Worm Ouroborus and the Zimiamvian trilogy.

David Lindsay, A Voyage to Arcturus.

(I think I recommend those to people, on average, about every six weeks. Oh, well.)

John Bellairs, The Face in the Frost.

James Branch Cabell, The Silver Stallion. (Yes, most Cabell readers would recommend Jurgen, I said these were personal favourites, didn’t I?)

Ranging a bit further afield, John Crowley’s Little, Big. Not any sort of traditional fantasy, but what other way can you classify it?

John Gardner’s Grendel and Freddy’s Book.

I recommend anything in Terry Pratchett’s Discworld series. Although you could try to read them chronologically (beginning with The Colour of Magic), I wouldn’t. Some of his later stuff is better. Mort, Small Gods, Lords and Ladies, Feet of Clay, or Soul Music are all books that can be read individually and be quite enjoyable.

I would also recommend Neil Gaiman. He only has three novels out, but they are all three quite excellent. Neverwhere, Stardust, and his recent book, American Gods, are wonderful reads. I saw him read from American Gods in June, and was quite entertained. Not only does he have an awesome British accent, he’s also pretty cute, and very funny.

But I digress. And of course, you have to read the result of the partnership of these two authors, Good Omens.

All this reminds me that I need to read more. Since September 11th, I’ve read very little (which is unusual for me.) It’s time to get back in the swing of things, and turn off the bleeping TV.

Patricia McKillip, The Riddlemaster of Hed. This is a wonderful novel, and a wonderful trilogy. It is also one of the few books that have made me cry.

I’ve read, and mostly enjoyed, most of the fantasy series mentioned here. Thanks for the recommendations on the more obscure stuff, especially from Steven Wright.

One author I stumbled on rather late is Guy Gavriel Kay. His fantasy novels have the richest, most well-developed characters and some of the best plots and settings of anything I’ve read. The man is an artist with a story, and is rarely if ever derivative, unless trying to adapt mythology or historical basis - which isn’t the same thing.
That’s my biggest complaint with some authors, btw.

All of his books are great, I’d start with Tigana (and did so).
The Lions of Al-Rassan would be the next choice. Amazingly good.

Ken Grimwood’s “Replay” (it won a World Fantasy Award, so it must be fantasy).

Tim Powers has written some truly great fantasy novels, like “The Anubis Gates” and “Last Call.”

There’s also Jim Morrow if you like something that’s both hilarious and philosophically challenging. Try “Only Begotten Daughter” or “Towing Jehovah.”

You might also try Esther Friesner.

Niven wrote some fantasy stories, BTW; they’re collected in “The Flight of the Horse.”

If you want a dark fantasy you might try the “Thomas Covenant” series by Donaldson. I do not remember the first one off the top of my head but there are nine books in total.

He also wrote a much more accessible 2 parter called “Mordant’s Need”, the first book being “Mirror of her Dreams”.

Daughter of the Forest by Juliet Marillier, a retelling – or rather expansion – of the fairy tale about the girl whose brothers were turned into swans. Really well written. Not so much a sword and sorcery tale, though.

I like a lot of Guy Kay’s stuff too.

Another great one, that I’m reading for the third or fourth time as we speak, is Richard Adams’s Maia. It’s got surprisingly little obvious magic for a fantasy novel (no Gandalf-esque wizards or dragons etc.) but it’s a wonderful book all the same, and one of my favorites. The fantasy is in the setting, I’d say, and the fact that Adams built this world (the Beklan empire) from the ground up. I’ve heard that it’s based loosely on ancient Greece, but I can’t remember where I read that. And talk about sagas… it’s long, over 1000 pages I think.

Maia is actually a prequel to Adams’s Shardik, which I haven’t yet read. Check libraries or used book stores for both; I think they’re out of print.

Also try P.C. Hodgell’s Dark of the Moon. I saw it mentioned a couple of times here, by magdalene and others, and it’s great. Not your usual fantasy at all.

The best fantasy series currently being published (because I say so, that’s why!) is George R.R. Martin’s “A Song of Ice and Fire.” It will be six books long when it’s completed; three are already out. The first is A Game of Thrones. His world is loosely based on England during the Wars of the Roses, and features literally dozens of speaking characters – but, remarkably, it’s not at all difficult to tell them apart or to remember their names. It’s an absolutely stunning achievement.

I’ll second the recommendation of Terry Pratchett – he’s funny and thought-provoking. His first few books are very jokey (and more specifically parodies than his later books became), so there are differences of opinion as to where to start. Some possibilities: The Colour of Magic (the first novel), Wyrd Sisters (the first really good one, which also introduces the small kingdom of Lancre and its witches), Small Gods (quite a bit later, but stands alone – much less humorous than most) and The Truth (very recent, also more or less stands alone, and shows Pratchett at his modern best).

Seconds also to Guy Gavriel Kay and Tim Powers (I particularly recommend his most recent novel, Declare, the secret magical history of the Cold War). Morrow’s really cool, too – Towing Jehovah is a powerful (and powerfully funny) book on many levels.

China Mieville has written an absolutely magnificent novel called Perdido Street Station that’s more fantasy than it is anything else. It’s set in a semi-industrial city (dirty and vibrant as London in Dickens’s day) and has an amazing array of characters, situations and activities. But it’s not for the faint of heart.

Neal Gaiman’s new novel American Gods is also very good – it’s one of the very few “Brit tries to explain all of American society and culture through fiction” pieces that I actually liked.

Steven Brust has a fast-paced and tongue in cheek series of novels about an assassin named Vlad Taltos – the first three novels are now available in an omnibus called The Book of Jhereg.

Sean Stewart has done some books I really loved (like Nobody’s Son – what happens after the low-born boy saves the kingdom and marries the princess – and Mockingbird – magical realism in Texas), and some that I found a tedious slog, like The Night Watch. Most of his books are very well-written at least; when he fails (in my opinion), it’s only through reaching too far.

Barry Hughart wrote three very funny novels set in mythic China, which were collected as The Chronicles of Master Li and Number Ten Ox. It’s out of print now, but may be findable; it’s well worth searching for.

And Sean Russell has written three two-book series that are fantasy mostly by courtesy (very little magic is done in them). The first was set in something like mythic China, and had great military maneuvering and tactics, and the other two had a world something like Georgian England, where magic was ebbing. His most recent book is a big epic fantasy in the George Martin mode, The One Kingdom, and it’s very good, too.

That’s probably too many already, so I’ll stop there.

Do a search on the board in the IMHO forum using the word “fantasy” in the thread title. You’ll find a bunch of threads with recommendations for good fantasy novels. Here’s my 20 favorite fantasy novels:

  1. Lewis Carroll Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass
  2. J. R. R. Tolkien The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings
  3. Peter Beagle The Last Unicorn
  4. Mervyn Peake The Gormenghast Trilogy
  5. C. S. Lewis Till We Have Faces
  6. Ursula K. LeGuin The Earthsea Books
  7. G. K. Chesterton The Man Who Was Thursday
  8. Madeleine L’Engle The Time Quartet (A Wrinkle in Time, The Wind in the Door, A Swiftly Tilting Planet, Many Waters)
  9. Ray Bradbury Dandelion Wine
  10. John Fowles The Magus
  11. T. H. White The Once and Future King
  12. Patricia McKillip Stepping from the Shadows
  13. C. S. Lewis The Ransom Trilogy (Out of the Silent Planet, Perelandra, and That Hideous Strength)
  14. R. A. McAvoy Tea with the Black Dragon
  15. H. P. Lovecraft The Dreamquest of Unknown Kadath
  16. John Myers Myers Silverlock
  17. Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman Good Omens
  18. L. Frank Baum The Wizard of Oz
  19. Daniel Pinkwater Borgel
  20. Mark Twain The Mysterious Stranger

I was going to recommend this trilogy myself. Since I can’t be the first to mention it, I’ll at least let you know that the first book is called “The Dragonbone Chair”. The series is long (the last book had to be two volumes when it went to paperback, since it just wasn’t possible to bind as one), but they are really worth it.

I’d also like to second Steven Brust. After you’ve dug into the Vlad Taltos books, be sure to check out the other books he wrote in the same world, such as “The Phoenix Guards” and “Brokedown Palace”.

If you want a good one-shot, Stephen King did one called “The Eyes of the Dragon” that was good.

I’ve read the following, which I highly recommend (these include science fiction):

J. R. R. Tolkien The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings and Silmarillion
Ursula K. LeGuin The Earthsea Books
T. H. White The Once and Future King The Book of Merlyn
C. S. Lewis Narnia Chronicles (mostly for children)
Walter Miller, A Canticle for Leibowitz
Frank Herbert Dune series
Bram Stoker, Dracula
Stephen Donaldson, the first three Chronicles of Thomas Covenant
anything by C.H. Cherryh, this woman (I presume the author is a woman deserves a Nobel prize for literature. The stuff is that good. Really interesting characters.)
anything by Larry Niven
Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
Foundation books by Issac Asimov (fun but not great literature)

David Eddings- “Belgariad” and “Mallorean” series

Stephen King- “Dark Tower” series (it’s not traditional fantasy but that seems to be the only genre it fits into.

Raymond E. Feist- “The Serpentwar Saga”

Kurt Vonnegut- “Slaughterhouse Five” and “Timequake” (the firsts thought-provoking and the second’s emotion-provoking)

I would add Raymond Feist’s Riftwar books, and the companion series written another author (I’m forgetting her name and not at home–but one of the books is called Daughter of the Empire) are good reads. Feist also has a modern story–similar to Stephen King’s good stuff–called Fairie Tale, whis is also quite good.

If you like modern fantasy, there is no better author than Charles DeLint. It’s not sword and sorcery fantasy, more like the magic realism of some of the South American writers. Some of his characters show up in several books, check out his short stories to get an overview of his world and characters. However, Somewhere To Be Flying can be read without any introduction to his world, and, in my opinion, is one of the best books, in any genre, ever written.