Okay so far, but I still have some questions. Essentially, I would like to know what are the frictional forces and their directions relative to the wheel. Maybe my terminology isn’t correct but I’ll try to explain what I mean.
Relating to the scenario 2. I posed earlier:
[QUOTE=zut]
If we’re talking about a tire rolling along a flat surface, the deceleration you see wouldn’t be coming from friction in the sense you’re thinking, it would be coming from tire flex. (Disclamer: tire dynamics and rolling resistance are somewhat far afield from my area of expertise, so… details may be fuzzy) As the tire rolls forward, the sidewalls on the leading edge of the tire contact patch are compressed, and the sidewalls on the trailing edge spring back (imagine rolling over a field of tiny springs). That creates a torque on the tire that will angularly decelerate it. Since we’re assuming no slip, the tire will also decelerate linearly, and the horizontal (x-direction) friction force will be whatever’s necessary to complete the force balance.
[/QUOTE]
All right, in this case, the decelaration comes from the tire flex. This creates a torque to the negative y-direction, so it creates an angular acceleration that opposes the rotation, thus decelarating the tyre. (This is a bit fuzzy now, maybe my terminology/understanding of the rolling resistance isn’t quite clear.) You could think of this torque to be created by the “frictional force” that slows down the tyre. How I understand this is that since the tire is rolling to the positive x-direction, from the point of view of the plane, the contact point of the tire could be considered to be trying to move to the negative x-direction. If there were no frictional forces, the tire would slip. Since we are assuming no slip, there has to a “frictional” force (a “static” frictional force, at that) that opposes this sliding, and this force has to point to the positive x-direction. And this force would result in the decelaration of angular motion, and thus also in the deceleration of the translational motion. Maybe that’s not what really happens, but I’m just trying to simplify things a bit.
And how about if we replace the tire with a perfectly rigid cylinder? Then the tire flex wouldn’t be a factor, but the cylinder should still slow down, if there’s friction between the cylinder and the plane.
[QUOTE=zut]
- I’m not sure what you’re asking here: the force exerted on the wheels by the belt is Fb, which, since it’s off-center, causes the angular acceleration of the wheels. A second force Fa between the belt and the wheels isn’t necessary.
[/QUOTE]
I wasn’t really clear before and I’m not sure if I’m any more clear now: The acceleration of the belt exerts a force on the wheels, but shouldn’t there also be a “frictional” force between the belt and the wheels that opposes the movement of the wheels on the belt, as in the case 2? If there wasn’t any friction between the belt and the tires, the motion of the belt wouldn’t have effect on the wheels, the wheels would just slide on the belt. So there has to be a frictional force to stop the wheels from sliding. To what direction does this frictional force point? (Maybe I should write “frictional” force, since the force opposing the rotation of the tires comes from tire flex (if I understood correctly), which should create a torque opposing the rotational motion of the tires.)