[QUOTE=zut]
And the reason this isn’t a very good analogy (bad Cecil!) is that this is a constant-speed conveyor, not one that is “designed to exactly match the speed of the wheels at any given time.” Everything you’ve stated above is true, but the problem statement leaves out the key “speed-matching” requirement.
Now, if you add that speed-matching requirment back in, then as soon as your buddy pushes forward, the treadmill will accelerate backwards to counteract the force, right? And what happens then depends on the other assumptions in the problem–friction, mass, and so forth. I’ve stuck every variation I can think of in post #106.
[/QUOTE]
Here’s the kicker…the force my friend is applying is going to be a constant additive force. As soon as the treadmill increases speed to match the initial push, if my friend is applying constant force, it will always be causing the wheels to spin at a faster speed than the treadmill.
Picture a balanced system, where the wheels are spinning at 10mph and the treadmill is going at a speed that counteracts that. As soon as my friend applies some force…say that would cause the wheels to turn 1mph more…the treadmill matches that. But that 1mph force is constant…when the new system is balanced at 11mph, that 1mph force is still there, and the forward movement continues…the treadmill is playing a constant game of catch-up and will never get there…