[QUOTE=David Simmons]
The problem of a wheel on a conveyer belt isn’t so difficult that it should take up all of this time. I went back to my old, old, physics text to review on rotary motion. Having done that I reproduced the development of the relationship between torque and angular acceleration. The development, of course, makes use of F = ma, some kinematic relationships between linear and angular acceleration and the definition of torque as a force at a distance from a center with the force being always at right angles to the line between the center and the point of application of the force.
The result is in this one page paper.
Having satisfied myself, if no one else, that a torque produces only rotation, I’ll apply that to a wheel on a conveyer belt in a later post.
[/QUOTE]
The analysis you are presenting is of a mass connected to a string with a force always applied tangential to the motion of the mass, right? (Just restating your picture in words.) This analysis is used to develop an expression for the angular acceleration of the radius line (the string, in other words).
The analysis is used to introduce the concept of angular acceleration. It’s not equivalent to the rotating wheel scenario for two reasons: 1. The force is always through the center of mass in the analysis you presented. 2. The point P (the center of rotation) is fixed, and thus it’s prevented from moving anywhere. As a consequence, there is a tension force transmitted through the string to the mass, so there are two forces applied to the mass: the force F and the string tension T. The string tension is, in fact, equal to m[symbol]w[/symbol][sup]2[/sup]r, where [symbol]w[/symbol] is the angular velocity of the string at that point.
So this analysis boils down to the following free body diagram (after, say, 90 degrees of rotation, just to pick a number):
*******
** **
** **
* *
* *
* *
T<----* O *
* *
* *
* *
** **
** **
*******
^
|
|
|
|
F
Both forces act through the center of mass of the mass m, acceleratiing the mass angularly (from force F) and radially (from force T). What’s more, the tension T is transmitted back to the ground through the point P.
We could also look at a diagram of the entire system, instead of just the mass m. In that case, we have this free body diagram (also shown after mass m has travelled 90 degrees:
P m
T<-- X==========O
^
|
|
F
where the tension in the string is transmitted to the ground at point P. This is an important point, because if you’re using this analysis as an analogy to the wheel situation, the wheel center is not fixed.
Now, just to keep this in perspective, let me post a free body diagram of a wheel on a treadmill. The wheel has some weight W, opposed by a normal force N. (We could just ignore these forces, if you like, since they always cancel out) and a tangential force F:
*******
** **
** **
* *
* *
* *
* O *
* *
* W *
* | *
** | **
** V **
*******<-------F
^
|
|
N
Now, the whole point is this: The force F is unbalanced. It must produce an acceleration because F=ma. That is essentially my argument: F=ma.