(This quote is from this Straight Dope classic by Cecil Adams.)
So Cecil Adams says Frankie Valli is a castrato? Is this true? He was actually castrated as a child to be a tenor as an adult?? I want to think Cecil Adams is joking, but he writes it in such a serious tone. No evidence whatsoever of a joke, at least in this part of what he is writing.
So what is it? Joke or the truth? Thank you in advance to all who reply
Okay number one, I’m a tenor. Being a tenor is very [checks] yes, very different from being a castrato. And yes, Cecil is joking. Had he decided to anwer the question just a couple years later, it would have been a Michael Jackson joke.
As Frankie Valli has been married for about 22 years, and fathered 3 children, the chances of him having been castrated as a child are not very likely.