The whole premise of the article is completely fucked up:
This Saturday marks the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. The semiquincentennial deserves more than the usual barbecues and neighborhood fireworks. It calls for a spectacle worthy of a quarter-millennium of American history.
In any such celebration, one ingredient is essential: a public face with an unmatched talent for promotion, crowd-drawing power, and sheer scale. In our timeline, that description fits Donald Trump perfectly. He is a master showman who knows how to make things big, loud, and unforgettable.
And then:
But imagine a different universe. One where Donald Trump is still larger-than-life, still talks like a born salesman, and still loves everything “YUGE.” He retains his flair for showmanship and his instinct for spectacle. Yet he is not polarizing. In this timeline, he avoids name-calling in public, steers clear of relitigating the 2020 election, and on January 6, 2021, firmly tells the protesters to go home peacefully.
The following is NOT to Godwinize the debate. Make no mistake, please. I’m not comparing Trump to a particular German dictator.
In alternative history scenarios, people suggest that the outcome could have a different if only X didn’t happen. No problem. The problem is when X runs fundamentally against the nature of the party doing the action.
The classic example is (to bore you with the details), people argue could have won WWII if only they didn’t invade Russia.
The problem is that Hitler was Hitler. He couldn’t help himself. The very nature that sent him down the path to invade Poland propelled him into the Soviet Union.
Trump is no evil genius, he’s a wannabe banana republic dictator and kleptocrat.
But just like Hitler’s personality was so extreme, Trump is fundamentally incapable of not making it all about himself.
There is no alternative universe where Trump is YUGE about anyone but himself because it’s impossible for him.
He has no agenda but self promotion and enrichment. He’s incapable of acting in the greater good. His “showmanship” and instinct for spectacle cannot exist outside of his polarization and attacking others. It’s who he is.
Why the fuck have sycophants like this author drank the Kool-Aid is beyond me, but they overlook the blatant lies and love him. The rest of us are turned off by the lies, so it would never have been a good 250th anniversary.
I don’t know how America recovers, if it does.