Talarico running on less than two years in the Senate would be a mistake. Not that it isn’t possible to win that way (thanks, Obama) but because Texas has a “resign to run” law.
I still think he’d be a great Secretary of State.
I don’t especially love him. I am open to him though. I think we need to find out if voters do. Not accepting your statement as fact. I do think he’d make a great president but I think there are several people possibly running on the D side who would. Heck
I am very much against Harris as candidate but think she’d be an excellent president.
A few people have said this…Obama had been in the Senate for FOUR years before being elected President.
Sure, I like the guy. He is my current favorite but I think you have misspoken here. If you want to say he hasn’t run for a statewide office yet and thus we don’t know how voters will treat him yet I can agree that is a valid unknown about Pete.
But voters don’t like him? Pete is one of the very few well known Democrats who still has a positive favorability rating. Newsom, AOC, and Harris are all underwater. The rest I would put into the not well known category.
I like him because he is fantastic on TV and unfortunately that seems to be what wins elections these days. Pete is great on Fox News, in town halls, or debating other candidates.
And the way to find that out is for him to run for something else.
I totally agree. I am pretty sure Mayor Pete would have whupped the GOP candidate in his district, making one more Dem in the House. Why didn’t he? I am disappointed.
This says he was wanting to run for President in 2028-
SAUGATUCK, Mich. (AP) — Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg announced that he will not seek an open U.S. Senate seat in Michigan, a move that leaves the door wide open for him to seek a much bigger role as his party’s next presidential nominee.
Since his role in the Biden administration ended in late January, Buttigieg has spent months considering his next move, including a serious look at the unexpectedly open U.S. Senate seat in Michigan, where he relocated in recent years. But many prominent allies he consulted believed he could not realistically pursue the Senate seat while keeping the door open for a 2028 presidential run.
Okay, not senate- then why not House? This makes no sense to me.
Running in the primaries will also answer the question. Can he do well in the first several states? No? Then voters don’t want to vote for dim. Yes? They do.
That only consults Democratic voters. Not Independent voters. And Buttigieg already ran for the Dem candidate for president- he lost badly.
After a poor showing in the South Carolina primary, Buttigieg suspended his campaign on March 1, 2020.[12]
There was also this-
In February 2020, a campaign finance watchdog group filed a Federal Election Commission (FEC) complaint alleging that the Buttigieg campaign coordinated with a Super PAC.[47] The complaint alleged that a tweet from a Buttigieg campaign was an attempt to bypass the FEC Act, which prohibits campaigns from coordinating with outside groups.[48]
Which is why South Carolina early is a key test for him. He doesn’t have to win but he needs a decent showing.
Winning a Congressional seat doesn’t mean as much regarding the national stage as doing well in the first several primaries would.
But winning a congressional seat would have given him two years of experience working with (in) Congress, which would make him more qualified to be president, imho.
I don’t disagree. But I don’t think the marginal voter cares about that.
He actually has run for statewide office. This was a core part of his feud with Klobuchar (who is probably Dems greatest electoral juggernaut by the numbers) because Pete ran for state treasurer and got crushed.
This shouldn’t specifically damn him as a candidate, some people are late bloomers. Ossoff came on the scene by losing very winnable GA-6 special election in 2017.
I like Mayor Pete. I’ve seen him speak. I think he’s smart and his goals are good. But i don’t think he’s the right man for the job. I don’t think he’d win, and even if he did, I’m dubious he has the connections and understanding is Congress to get his agenda done.
Expanding -
There are parallel questions in this thread:
Who do we think would be the best general election candidate?
Who do we personally think would be the best president?
And who do we think will be the candidate and also the final round candidates into the stretch?
I personally see lots of talent and multiple good choices.
In terms of best general election candidate reliable Democratic and reliable Republican voters will be out in any case.
The marginal voters matter: those who reliably vote one way or the other but don’t necessarily reliably vote (turnout for and/or against); and swing/independent voters, who also may or may not be inspired to vote, and some of whom are the low information contingent.
I think in our current era those marginal voters don’t care if the candidate has governing experience, if anything the record created by even a short time governing can be an albatross - creating votes that can be highlighted to make someone unhappy, some inconsistencies, some compromise that some fraction doesn’t like, or the other fraction doesn’t.
The have a beer with test is a bit silly, but I do think the gut check test matters to these voters first and foremost. Not whether or not they have been in the House, Senate, or governor’s mansion.
The possibly winning the D nod is based on other factors, including having the infrastructure prepared for the run, and a strategy that can get you there. My sense is that Buttigieg has the infrastructure by now, and he has a strategy. I don’t know if it will get him there. But its first big test is not getting knocked out in South Carolina.
Yeah, regardless of whether one considers it strictly necessary, winning a congressional seat would certainly make Buttigieg a stronger candidate. And he’s in a district where he probably could have won. And he didn’t run.
Why not? I think that we really want to know the reason for that, at the least, before considering him as a presidential candidate. And most of the potential answers I can think of, starting with “he’s just tired of politics”, would also be disqualifying for a Presidential run.
What strategy includes “choose not to run for a House seat” as a step?
The strategy that supported a first attempt with only Mayor under the belt and that has since been Transportation Secretary building political relationships, and becoming a known liked figure even to those who watch Fox. Again I see little evidence that the marginal voter, or even the typical primary voter cares at all about having a term in the House or such as a prereq. OTOH a legislative record can haunt you.
It is strategy that considers the resume as actually not so important to most voters.
He has name recognition without huge negatives attached. (Few feel strongly that they would make effort to vote against him; even those who disagree with him generally like him - the anti-Cruz.)
He has fund raising capacity.
He is media savvy and skillful, including in unfriendly venues.
He has built a national political network.
He is selling generational change with a pragmatic approach.
And he has invested effort to fix the big gaping hole in his path - his past weakness with many Black voters, especially in South Carolina.
If his efforts at that repair pay off enough that he has a fair showing there then he is a top contender. Not a sure thing but in for the duration. Blown out of the water there and he should hang it up.
Among the apparent qualifications for President is holding a high office previously. Vance (Vice Pres.), Rubio (Sec’y State) and DeSantis (Gov. of a major state) may be the three top GOP contenders and they do well by that criterion.
Only two in all of history have been elevated from the House of Reps directly to the White House: Lincoln and Garfield. (Garfield was a polymath and sort of a Senator-elect.) Will AOC try to join that select crew?
Three Senators have been promoted from the Senate directly to POTUS: Harding, JFK and Obama. (Harding had also served as Ohio’s Lieut. Gov.) Those are tough shoes for Ossoff to fill.
And either AOC and Ossoff would become the youngest POTUS ever if elected.
Buttigieg’s highest elected office is Mayor. But other top contenders for the Democratic nomination include 3 Governors and a Vice President.
I’m offering no opinion here on electability; and of course it would be inspiring if a young woman takes over from the senescent Orange Monster. Just repeating some facts.
And historically military leadership.
Of course if that was an absolute qualification for getting elected we’d have no Trump as president.
Okay the list of those who got elected to president without previously been elected to high office or being a general is not huge or full of our best: beyond Trump there are Hoover and Taft - but Trump’s success at getting elected is a distinct counter to the argument that voters consider previously winning or at least holding high office a necessary qualification.