[QUOTE=Dead Badger]
I might agree with you; however, the new format is one of the major selling points of the new suite (possibly even bigger than the new UI), and having the software not use it by default would set back its adoption for a long time.
[/QUOTE]
And that’s really what it’s about. How many people are content to stay with Word 2007? Probably quite a few. But if you throw out a new format and force its adoption by creating a new default format, well, suddenly you’ve got a few more converts.
[QUOTE=Dead Badger]
Besides which, you can change the default save format in the options: Excel Options > Save > “Save files in this format”. So: they’ve provided a compatibility patch. They’ve made it so you can just use the old formats anyway. If you want, you can pretend the new formats don’t exist at all, and all it takes is about five clicks. If this is unacceptable, how are any new features supposed to be implemented at all?
[/QUOTE]
Here’s the thing, though. The .doc format has been around for over a decade. People are used to MS Word saving things as .doc. People don’t give it a second thought that the file they save will be a .doc and will work on whatever computer has to open the file. So if you’re going to do something like change this long-established, highly-ingrained default, it better be 1) with a lot of thought, and 2) for a reason better than it’ll get you more users.
I like new features as much as the next guy, but my problem with it is I don’t see why it couldn’t have been an option to save as .docx, like .rtf and .txt are options. That way, if you want that format, you can choose it, and the people who don’t want it don’t need to change the way they work and everybody won’t have to remember that the default has changed.
It took me about 15 minutes to realize the cause of my file problems were because the format had changed. If I had my computer set to not show me file suffixes, I may have never figured it out. When doing basic troubleshooting for this kind of thing, who the hell thinks to ask whether the default file format has changed? Most people would just think the file was corrupted.
[QUOTE=Dead Badger]
Your IT department is so incompetent that they won’t roll out a simple compatibility patch for the most-used productivity suite in the entire world? Then to be honest, you’ve got far more serious problems than file incompatibility. Managing Office transitions is one of the main things corporate IT do, and all the tools were in place to make this one pretty seamless. Again, not Microsoft’s fault if people don’t use them.
[/QUOTE]
Our IT security policy is more or less dictated by our clients. We do a lot of high-profile DVD, dubbing, theatrical, and game localization work, and one of our selling points is our high security. Furthermore, we did not adopt Word 2007 company-wide. The Word 2007 file was sent by one of our private contractors, from his own computer. To date it’s still the only Word 2007 file I’ve seen here.