GoDaddy Website Payment Question

I realize this is weirdly specific, but I’m hoping someone has already solved this for me. GoDaddy customer support can’t really help me. Trust me, I’ve tried.

I manage a website on GoDaddy for a local club. It currently has no e-commerce, but I need to add the ability for a member to renew their membership online using a credit card. I figured out how to do that, but I have now been told that members have to be able to check a box and their membership will be renewed automatically without them having to do anything.

I assumed there was some way to do this using the GoDaddy website builder toolkit, but according to GoDaddy support, it’s not possible, even using their Square payment plugin, which means I have to link to some external payment system that uses credit cards AND has a feature that allows for auto-renewals.

Does anyone know a fairly easy way to do this? BTW, I am not a programmer, so it can’t involve coding something within GoDaddy.

So why not link to an external payment system that uses credit cards and has a feature that allows for auto-renewals? For example Paypal?