Prepare ahead of time a square array of numbers (in my example, I’ll use a 5 x 5 array, but you can make it any size as long as it has the same number of rows as columns), by writing any numbers across the top, and any numbers down the side, and then filling in the array by making each entry = the sum of the number at the top of its column and the number at the beginning of its row. Fow example,
1 2 3 4 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
2 3 4 5 6 7
4 5 6 7 8 9
6 7 8 9 10 11
8 9 10 11 12 13
Now prepare a sheet of paper with just the square array on it (not the numbers across the top & sides). Also, ahead of time add up all the numbers across the top and down the side, write this total (in my example, 1+2+3+4+5+0+2+4+6+8=35) on a slip of paper or index card, and put it in a sealed envelope, and leave it lying on your desk or give it to a student and tell them not to open it until you tell them to.
Now, hand the array of numbers to someone, and tell them to pick any number and circle it. Then, cross out all the other numbers in that same row and all the other numbers in that same column.
Now hand it to someone else, and ask them to pick any of the remaining numbers (that haven’t been circled or crossed out), circle it, and then cross out every other number in its row and column.
Keep doing this until all the numbers are either circled or crossed out. (Each row and each column will have exactly one circled number in it.)
Now, ask someone to add up all the circled numbers and tell you the total.
Ask someone else to open the sealed envelope and tell you what number is inside. They should be the same.
(This trick, and the previous one, I got from books by Martin Gardner.)