This could be a Cafe Society thread if it didn’t have the guessing game as its main feature.
It could be a Game Room thread if it weren’t for all the movie references.
It may not even matter.
==============================
The idea is to list some props, or some references in the dialog to some peculiar objects, that ought to give those who’ve seen the movie (or at least scenes from it) a good idea of what movie is involved.
If more than one movie has such objects, keep naming them until you have a more or less unique movie described.
If somebody guesses another movie from the one you have in mind, name some more props in your movie to help distinguish it from the one(s) guessed.
==============================
Props #1
a fish wrapped in a bulletproof vest
a baptismal font
a shotgun in a flower box
Props #2
a set of steak knives
a pack of sales leads
a Cadillac
Props #3
an electroshock device
a sink
a basketball goal
Props #4
switchblades
a tire iron
a compact
a milk bottle
a painting on the floor
Props #5
a telephoto lens
flashbulbs
an overnight case
a dog in a basket
a saw
=====================
Please use numbers to refer to groups of props, and try to keep them in order.